﻿<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.2 20190208//EN" "JATS-archivearticle1.dtd"[]>
<article xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" dtd-version="1.2" article-type="research-article">
  <front>
    <journal-meta>
      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">ijese</journal-id>
      <journal-title-group>
        <journal-title>Interdisciplinary Journal of Environmental and Science
Education</journal-title>
      </journal-title-group>
      <issn publication-format="electronic">2633-6537</issn>
      <publisher>
        <publisher-name>Modestum</publisher-name>
      </publisher>
    </journal-meta>
    <article-meta>
      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.29333/ijese/14339</article-id>
      <title-group>
        <article-title>Evolution of an introductory undergraduate biology course
through collaborative action research</article-title>
      </title-group>
      <contrib-group>
        <contrib contrib-type="author" corresp="yes">
          <contrib-id contrib-id-type="orcid">0000-0002-1047-8513</contrib-id>
          <name>
            <surname>Kazempour</surname>
            <given-names>Mahsa</given-names>
          </name>
          <email>muk30@psu.edu</email>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-1" />
          <xref ref-type="corresp" rid="cor-true">
            <sup>*</sup>
          </xref>
        </contrib>
        <contrib contrib-type="author">
          <contrib-id contrib-id-type="orcid">0000-0001-8023-4605</contrib-id>
          <name>
            <surname>Amirshokoohi</surname>
            <given-names>Aidin</given-names>
          </name>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-2" />
        </contrib>
        <contrib contrib-type="author">
          <contrib-id contrib-id-type="orcid">0000-0002-7855-536X</contrib-id>
          <name>
            <surname>Goudsouzian</surname>
            <given-names>Lara</given-names>
          </name>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-2" />
        </contrib>
        <aff id="aff-1">
          <label>1</label>
          <institution-wrap>
            <institution>Penn State University-Berks, Reading, PA, USA</institution>
          </institution-wrap>
        </aff>
        <aff id="aff-2">
          <label>2</label>
          <institution-wrap>
            <institution>DeSales University, Center Valley, PA, USA</institution>
          </institution-wrap>
        </aff>
      </contrib-group>
      <pub-date date-type="pub" publication-format="electronic" iso-8601-date="2024-03-08">
        <day>8</day>
        <month>3</month>
        <year>2024</year>
      </pub-date>
      <volume>20</volume>
      <issue>1</issue>
      <elocation-id>e2403</elocation-id>
      <permissions>
        <copyright-statement>Copyright © 2024 by Author/s and Licensed by
Modestum DOO, Serbia.</copyright-statement>
        <copyright-year>2024</copyright-year>
        <license license-type="open-access" xlink:href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/">
          <license-p>This is an open access article distributed under the Creative
Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work
is properly cited.</license-p>
        </license>
      </permissions>
      <abstract>
        <p>
Over the past few decades, we have witnessed an increasing emphasis on
the significance of restructuring and revolutionizing undergraduate
science education in achieving the goal of preparing a scientifically
literate population and safeguarding our democracy and the future of
STEM workforce. This paper reports on a collaborative action research
conducted to reform and modify an introductory undergraduate biology
course taught by the third author with professional support and feedback
provided by the other authors. The findings will be discussed in the
form of a case study focusing on the initial features of the course,
continual feedback and professional growth, modifications to the course,
and future plans for further revising the course.
</p>
      </abstract>
      <kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
        <kwd>college science course</kwd>
        <kwd>college science teaching</kwd>
        <kwd>biology education</kwd>
        <kwd>action research</kwd>
        <kwd>course revision</kwd>
      </kwd-group>
    </article-meta>
  </front>
  <body>
    <sec id="introduction">
      <title>INTRODUCTION</title>
      <p>Over the past few decades, reform documents such as <italic>From
  analysis to action</italic> (National Research Council [NRC], 1996),
  <italic>Shaping the future</italic> (National Science Foundation,
  1996), <italic>Science teacher preparation in an era of
  standards-based reform</italic> (NRC, 1997), <italic>Reinventing
  undergraduate education: A blueprint for America’s
  universities</italic> (Boyer Commission on Educating Undergraduates in
  the Research University, 1998), and <italic>College pathways to the
  science education standards</italic> (Siebert &amp; McIntosh, 2001)
  have underscored the significance of undergraduate science education
  in achieving the goal of preparing a scientifically literate
  population and safeguarding our democracy and the future of STEM
  workforce. There have been numerous calls for transforming
  undergraduate science courses and laboratory experiences from the
  traditional instructional approaches of lecture, teacher-directed
  activities, direct transformation of information, and passive student
  learning to student-centered and active learning experiences that
  allow for greater student engagement in the learning process and
  higher order thinking (Donovan &amp; Bransford, 2005; Freeman et al.,
  2014).</p>
      <p>Although there may exist various definitions and visions of what
  active learning in undergraduate STEM education may entail, all agree
  on certain features that distinguish this approach from the
  traditional, teacher-directed approach. In 2009, the American
  Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS, 2009) published
  <italic>Vision and change: Call to action,</italic> which describes
  six core competencies central to student-centered undergraduate
  biology education, which include: applying the process of science,
  employing quantitative reasoning, using modeling and simulation, and
  focusing on the interdisciplinary nature of science and its
  interconnection with society. Similarly, Olson and Riordon (2012)
  recommended multiple changes to undergraduate STEM education including
  “the adoption of evidence-based teaching practices”. All active
  learning approaches meet some criteria of either the cognitive
  (Piagetian) constructivist learning theory focusing on students’
  active and direct engagement with the subject matter or the social
  constructivist (Vygotskyian) lens, which also underscores the
  importance of actively engaging with other individuals for in-depth
  learning and construction of understanding to occur (Arthurs &amp;
  Kreager, 2017; Freeman et al., 2014), The key distinction from the
  traditional framework lies in the active and interactive engagement of
  students in tasks that result in deeper cognitive and collaborative
  learning as opposed to a passive and disengaged learning process in
  the traditional approach (Chi, 2009; Chi &amp; Wylie, 2014).</p>
      <p>Benefits of more active and student-centered instruction include
  enhanced student performance, improved affect, decreased failure
  rates, and development of conceptual understanding and scientific
  thinking skills (Ballen et al., 2017; Eddy &amp; Hogan, 2014; Crouch
  &amp; Mazur, 2001; Freeman et al., 2014; Haak et al., 2011; Theobald
  et al., 2020). The advantageous effects have been shown to be greater
  among the most at risk and underrepresented student groups (Ballen et
  al., 2017; Beichner et al., 2007; Haak et al., 2011). Furthermore,
  meta-analysis by Theobald et al. (2020) and other research findings
  (Ballen et al., 2017; Eddy &amp; Hogan, 2014; Haak et al., 2011)
  indicate increased diversification of STEM graduates, more equitable
  outcomes, and narrower achievement gaps for underrepresented students
  in STEM disciplines.</p>
      <p>Despite the plentiful benefits of learner-engaged instructional
  approaches and the numerous efforts witnessed at various institutions
  of higher education to reform undergraduate science education (e.g.,
  Baldwin, 2009; Kazempour &amp; Amirshokoohi, 2013), the change has not
  been significant and widespread (Barr &amp; Tagg, 2008; Brownell &amp;
  Tanner, 2012). This is especially true for introductory courses that
  tend to be broader in scope and content and larger in class size. Such
  courses often serve as the initial and often sole opportunity to
  appeal to or deter students from pursuing paths in STEM fields as well
  as gain scientific knowledge and STEM related skills of problem
  solving, critical thinking, decision making, communication, and
  collaboration that are critical for achieving scientific literacy
  (AAAS, 2009; NRC, 2003; Seymour, 2002).</p>
      <p>A key challenge to meeting the calls for undergraduate science
  education reform has been convincing science faculty that their
  instructional approach, which they witnessed during their own
  undergraduate experience and have utilized for years and even decades,
  may not be effective and require change (Brownell &amp; Tanner, 2012).
  Three key factors of lack of training, time, and incentives have been
  identified as impeding faculty instructional change. Science faculty
  are often ill-equipped to modify their instructional approach due to
  lack of prior training and the consequent lack of pedagogical
  knowledge about teaching and learning theories, classroom management,
  enhancing student learning, motivation, and engagement, as well as
  evaluating student learning and engagement (Hativa, 1995; Hanson &amp;
  Moser, 2003; Luft et al., 2004; Yarnall et al., 2007). Prior studies
  (e.g., Dancy et al., 2016; Smith et al., 2009; Stains &amp; Vickrey
  2017) have indicated that even when it comes to active learning
  strategies, instructors may implement such strategies differently than
  intended and that their instructional decisions may impact student
  learning in a significant manner. To address the issue with science
  faculty’s limited pedagogical knowledge it is imperative to provide
  them access to formal training and ongoing professional development
  and continuing and iterative opportunities to apply and practice what
  they learn and evaluate the efficacy of the new approaches when
  implemented in the classroom (AAAS, 2009).</p>
      <p>Research studies on undergraduate science education mainly focus on
  outcomes of revising science content courses, including student
  achievement, success or failure rates, student attitudes, and impact
  on achievement gap. However, the literature is devoid of studies
  focusing on the effects of the professional development experience on
  the faculty member’s instructional behaviors and decisions. The nature
  and extent of revisions and modifications that are made to such
  courses are most often not reported. Therefore, it is critical to
  focus on evaluating the impact of training and professional
  development on instructional decisions and actions and disseminate
  description of such changes in order to encourage other science
  faculty to consider making similar changes and provide them beneficial
  examples that they may emulate in their own courses.</p>
      <p>We conducted a multi-year collaborative action research study in an
  effort to reform and modify an introductory undergraduate biology
  course taught by the third author with professional support and
  feedback provided by the first two authors. In the current paper, we
  aim to discuss, in the form of a case study, our findings with respect
  to:</p>
      <list list-type="alpha-lower">
        <list-item>
          <p>the initial features of the course components of lecture,
      laboratory, and homework,</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>initial feedback provided by the science educators,</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>changes to course components after collaborative professional
      development, and</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>additional recommendations and plans for the next phase of
      course revisions.</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p>In another article (in review), we focus on the instructor’s
  initial and evolving beliefs about science and science teaching,
  motivation to embark on a professional development and course
  revision, ongoing reflections on the professional development and
  course modification experiences, and barriers and concerns impeding
  possible changes in her instructional practice.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="materials-methods">
      <title>MATERIALS &amp; METHODS</title>
      <sec id="context">
        <title>Context</title>
        <p>This collaborative action research focuses on an introductory
    undergraduate science course at a Northeastern private university.
    The course, ‘thinking and creativity’ is one of the ‘modes of
    thinking’ natural science course options that must be taken by all
    students at this institution. The typical class size is
    approximately 40-45 students. The course includes a 50-minute
    lecture session twice a week with a two-hour weekly laboratory.
    According to the institutional course catalog, the course is
    described as one focusing on the “thoughts and methods of
    biologists” with the lecture component “centered on topics in human
    physiology, examining the scientific method and practical examples
    of its use” while the “laboratory component examines methods of
    obtaining scientific data, using the course participants as
    subjects.” (course syllabus, p. 1). The student learning objectives
    include:</p>
        <list list-type="order">
          <list-item>
            <p>describing differing levels of biological organization,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>explaining importance of DNA as molecule of heredity,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>demonstrating an understanding of human biology, including
        the anatomy and physiology of major organ systems, and</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>designing and completing a research project that includes
        generating a scientific question, formulating a hypothesis,
        creating an experimental design, collecting and analyzing
        data.</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
        <p>The course instructor (third author) is an associate professor
    responsible for teaching intermediate and advanced molecular biology
    courses as well as cancer biology and biology courses for
    non-majors. She had taught the course of focus only once before
    initiating the study. At the time of the study, the second author
    was an associate professor of STEM education at the same institution
    and is mainly responsible for teaching science methods, math
    methods, STEM education, technology education, and designing
    instruction courses in the elementary education program. His areas
    of research include, among other things, pre-service teacher
    preparation focusing on both content and methods courses as well as
    teacher professional development. The first author is an associate
    professor of science education at a nearby public four-year
    university and is mainly responsible for teaching science methods
    courses for elementary pre-service teachers and environmental
    science and sustainability courses for non-science majors. She also
    focuses on pre-service teacher preparation and teacher professional
    development as part of her scholarly activity.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="collaborative-action-research">
        <title>Collaborative Action Research</title>
        <p>Action research involves a recurrent, systematic, and reflective
    process of planning, implementation, monitoring, evaluation, and
    reflection to allow for examination and improvement of instructional
    practices and contribute to the body of research on teaching and
    learning (Carr &amp; Kemmis, 1986; Feldman &amp; Minstrell, 2000)
    similar to ones conducted by other science educators (e.g.,
    Capobianco, 2007; van Zee et al., 2003). We took a collaborative
    approach to our action research (Loucks-Horsley et al., 1998) by
    jointly embarking on a process of descriptive reporting, problem
    solving, critical reflection, collaborative discussion and support,
    and professional practice in order to improve the instructor’s
    instructional practice in order to enhance students’ learning
    experiences in the introductory science course. <bold><xref ref-type="fig" rid="figure-4509">Figure 1</xref></bold> summarizes four phases of action research process that will
    be described below.</p>
        <p>This action research was initiated when the third author
    approached the first and second authors, both science and/or STEM
    educators, about her interest in discussing ways to improve the
    quality of her course instruction in order to engage students and
    fulfill the objectives of the course more effectively. Her interest
    in initiating this effort stemmed from her recent exposure to
    ‘active learning’ ideas as part of her involvement in the biology
    education community and participation in recent conferences. She had
    also come across the teaching and research work of the second author
    through cross departmental initiatives and teacher certification
    teaching, advising, and coordinating that the second author was
    responsible for. We decided that it would be most appropriate to
    begin with thoroughly examining the course content and instruction
    in its original format and provide feedback to the instructor and
    then re-examine the course instruction one year later once the
    instructor had the opportunity to modify the course based on the
    previously provided and ongoing feedback and resources.</p>
        <p>In the first iteration of the study, the first and second authors
    began with an analysis of course instruction using the video
    recordings of the lecture sessions as well as examining syllabus and
    other documents such as assignment instructions and laboratory
    handouts. We provided the course instructor with thorough written
    feedback on her instruction for each class session as well as on the
    various homework assignments and laboratory instructions handouts.
    We also provided her with general overall feedback and suggestions
    in order to make her course more effective and inquiry-based. This
    was followed with several rounds of discussions of the feedback to
    clarify any areas that needed further explanation and ensure that
    the course instructor understood the feedback and ways to make the
    necessary changes in her course.</p>
        <p>The following fall semester, the course instructor used the
    feedback to make some changes to the course before teaching it again
    in the spring. During this second iteration of teaching the course,
    the data collected and examined included video recordings of the
    class sessions, course instructor’s reflections about changes made
    to each lecture and lab session and her thoughts and experiences
    throughout the semester, course assignment instructions and
    laboratory handouts, as well as post interviews with the course
    instructor to further discuss her thoughts and experiences
    throughout the process.</p>
        <p>The instructor’s reflections were read on a weekly basis and the
    other authors provided her with feedback and responded to questions
    or concerns mentioned by the instructor. The video recordings and
    assignment instructions handouts were examined and analyzed
    next.</p>
        <p>Finally, a semi-structured interview was conducted to ascertain
    more information about the instructor’s beliefs, experiences, and
    challenges or difficulties faced during the revision process. The
    data from the second phase of the research was cross examined with
    the initial set of data to explore similarities and differences and
    possible changes that may have occurred.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="data-collection-analysis">
        <title>Data Collection &amp; Analysis</title>
        <p>As described in the above section, there were multiple forms of
    data that were collected throughout the various phases of the
    collaborative action research. These included:</p>
        <list list-type="alpha-lower">
          <list-item>
            <p>video recordings of the lecture sessions both before and
        after the changes,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>artifacts such as course syllabi, assignment instructions,
        homework assignments, laboratory handouts, and PowerPoint
        slides, and</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>instructor reflections, email correspondence between
        researchers and instructor, and final instructor interview.</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
        <p>The video recordings of the lecture sessions as well as the
    associated presentation slides were analyzed by each researcher for
    the dual purpose of providing immediate or gradual feedback and
    comments to the instructor as well as identifying patterns in
    instructional approaches, strategies, and areas of strength and
    weakness for pre and post comparisons. Laboratory handouts and
    homework assignments were similarly analyzed for key features, areas
    requiring change, and possible evidence about the instructor’s
    teaching decisions and actions as well as implementation of
    suggested revisions. Email correspondence between the instructor and
    researchers, the ongoing instructor reflections, the continual
    gradual feedback from the educator researchers, as well as the final
    instructor interview were content analyzed.</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="results">
      <title>RESULTS</title>
      <p>The findings will be discussed in the following sections:</p>
      <list list-type="alpha-lower">
        <list-item>
          <p>the initial features of the course components of lecture,
      laboratory, and homework,</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>initial feedback provided by the science educators,</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>changes to course components after collaborative professional
      development and initial feedback, and</p>
        </list-item>
        <list-item>
          <p>additional recommendations and plans for the next phase of
      modifying the course.</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <sec id="original-course-features">
        <title>Original Course Features</title>
        <p>The results of the initial phase of analysis focusing on the key
    features of the course as it was originally structured are described
    with respect to the course components of lecture, laboratory, and
    homework discussed in the below sections and summarized in
    <bold><xref ref-type="table" rid="table-17">Table 1</xref></bold>.</p>
        <sec id="lecture-sessions">
          <title>Lecture Sessions</title>
          <p>The instructor’s lecture presentations had a few effective
      elements including the use of relevant and attention-grabbing
      images on the presentations slides as well as an effective
      narrative presentation format and use of analogies throughout the
      presentation. This combination of features allowed the lecture
      sessions to appear relatively engaging and the content simple to
      comprehend by the students. However, our observations of the
      lecture session revealed a number of areas that required
      modification. First, the lecture focused extensively on human
      biology with minimum attention to the process of science, with the
      exception of an initial session devoted at least partially to the
      discussion of the ‘the scientific method’. There was little to no
      student exposure to and engagement in the process of scientific
      inquiry and the brief discussion of the scientific method model,
      early in the semester, did not include reference to other modes of
      investigation besides experiments. Additionally, the lecture
      sessions were too information-laden and focused on the coverage of
      content, which is the product of science, as opposed to the
      understanding of the process of arriving at that knowledge. This
      could potentially lead to multiple issues including student
      misconception about science being a large body of unrelated and
      trivial facts. Furthermore, instructor questions posed to the
      students were limited and often only served as quick review of
      content covered. Finally, most of the lecture sessions mainly
      consisted of instructor delivery of information with extremely
      limited, or even non-existent, peer discussion or collaboration
      among students.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="homework">
          <title>Homework</title>
          <p>There were 10 homework assignments distributed on an almost
      weekly basis throughout the semester. During our initial analysis
      of the existing homework assignments, we noted that they consisted
      of mainly lower-level thinking and simplified tasks, which
      included a limited number of questions that were mainly
      closed-ended in nature. Almost all the questions focused on simple
      information recall and knowledge of terminology rather than a deep
      understanding of concepts learned or addressed in lecture. The
      homework tasks did not consist of any critical thinking, problem
      solving, in-depth analysis, or communication and collaboration
      with peers.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="laboratory-sessions">
          <title>Laboratory sessions</title>
          <p>The laboratory handouts were mainly instructions for students
      to perform during the laboratory sessions. Nearly all of the
      handouts included information and description of content that were
      previously discussed in the related lecture session, including the
      explanation of the terminology and concepts that students should
      have already become familiarized with or been able to apply in the
      laboratory session. The laboratory instructions handouts included
      very few questions, which were mainly included at the end of the
      handout for students to respond to at the completion of the
      laboratory investigation. Similar to the homework assignments,
      questions included on the laboratory handouts were simple and
      closed-ended in nature. A few of the laboratory instructions
      handouts, such as the ‘cells’ lab, included some possible
      anticipated ‘observations’ or ‘results’, which inevitably meant
      that students were simply conducting the laboratory tasks and
      investigations to confirm or simply observe the expected outcomes
      and descriptions provided by the instructor. This implied that
      there was an expectation to obtain certain results that were
      deemed ‘correct’ and corresponded with what was previously
      discussed.</p>
        </sec>
      </sec>
      <sec id="initial-feedback">
        <title>Initial Feedback</title>
        <p>Upon completion of our initial observations, we communicated our
    feedback about the course and its components with the instructor and
    had numerous follow-up discussions with her to clarify areas that
    required further elaboration. As general feedback to the instructor
    we recommended that since the course is identified as a ‘mode of
    thinking’ natural science course for all majors, the focus should be
    on examining and employing science practices, critical thinking,
    problem solving, research, information literacy, and application of
    content to the real world. We argued that the course biology content
    should be treated as the ‘context’ for engaging students in
    understanding the scientific inquiry process and not the focus of
    the course itself. This would allow students to leave the course
    with an understanding of how scientists, in particular biologists,
    engage in scientific inquiry and what that process involves.</p>
        <sec id="lecture">
          <title>Lecture</title>
          <p>With respect to the lecture sessions, we recommended
      structuring the lecture so that the focus would be on the process
      of scientific inquiry and allow the lecture session to serve as
      opportunities for students to think about and possibly engage in
      some aspects of the process of science such as using curiosity,
      inquiring, making observations and inferences, asking questions,
      analyzing evidence, discussing and communicating with peers,
      referring to literature, and recognizing the connection of science
      to real life as discussed in the nature of science and inquiry
      readings and supplemental materials. Furthermore, we emphasized
      the need for the lecture to address the cyclical and complex
      process of scientific inquiry (Understanding Science, 2022)
      illustrated in <bold><xref ref-type="fig" rid="figure-4510">Figure 2</xref></bold>, as opposed to the simplistic
      and linear scientific method model and shared several readings and
      resources with the instructor to clarify the distinction.</p>
          <p>In line with that suggestion, we also discussed the importance
      of including various forms of scientific investigations, including
      descriptive, comparative, and modeling as the focus of lecture and
      laboratory sessions rather than only focusing on experimental
      investigations. We clarified our argument by providing multiple
      examples related to her lecture sessions including the
      following:</p>
          <disp-quote>
            <p>The example of Jenner for the process of science discussion
        was good, but perhaps start with a brief video to expose the
        students to the story and then have them think about how it
        reflects the process of science before you discuss it. We would
        suggest allowing them to actually think as a small team before
        opening it up to class discussion. The story of Jenner actually
        lines up well with the science inquiry model because he did not
        start out with a question, and it was rather by serendipity and
        observations. Also, it would be effective to point out that his
        investigation was not an experimental one and that there was a
        societal context. Again, those are not reflected in the
        typically referenced scientific method model but clearly shown
        on the science inquiry model.</p>
          </disp-quote>
          <p>We also recommended that the lecture sessions be focused on
      essential questions, questions that drive inquiry and critical
      thinking, rather than merely meeting a list of objectives.
      Furthermore, we suggested shifting from ‘telling’ and
      ‘teacher-directed instruction’ to active, student-centered
      learning by utilizing the 5E learning cycle model (Bybee, 1997),
      which is based on the constructivist framework of learning. We
      explained that it is best to initiate the learning experience with
      an engaging introduction that captivates student attention and
      piques their interest and curiosity and provides them a problem,
      case, or scenario to think about and serve as the contexts for the
      discussion of the topic. Once engaged, students should be provided
      opportunities for initial exploration, analysis of evidence, peer
      discussion of cases, scenarios, and problems, and other
      collaborative tasks. This would then be followed with discussions
      of their findings and observations to introduce key ideas and
      concepts. To further elucidate our suggestions and feedback, we
      provided a number of examples including the following:</p>
          <disp-quote>
            <p>For the discussion about carbohydrates and anabolic steroids,
        you could have provided a simple task such as giving students
        the structure of the different groups (carbs, proteins, lipids)
        and foods containing them and having them think about
        commonalities and differences among the categories. The
        questions you posed to them about carbs and body builders could
        also be provided for them to think about and discuss as part of
        this task or small discussions interspersed in the lecture.</p>
          </disp-quote>
          <p>Finally, we emphasized the importance of asking questions and
      class discussions in driving the lecture and similarly allowing
      students to be actively engaged in asking questions and inquiring
      about things in order to see the significance of questions in the
      process of scientific inquiry. The instructor inquired about
      further examples to help her implement the changes we had proposed
      and asked that we use the topic of ‘digestion’ as a sample topic
      to explain how we would suggest changing that component of the
      lecture. We provided her with a description of possible ideas that
      tied in with the various pedagogical suggestions we had
      recommended earlier.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="homework-1">
          <title>Homework</title>
          <p>In our initial feedback on the homework assignments, we
      discussed the need for allowing more opportunities for students to
      apply the content by incorporating questions and tasks that would
      require in-depth thinking of the content and applying their new
      understanding or the content addressed to new situations and
      examples. We also emphasized the importance of focusing on
      real-life connections and ensuring that students recognize the
      relevance of content addressed in the course. Finally, we stressed
      the need to create more meaningful homework assignments by
      incorporating appropriate questions that allow in-depth critical
      thinking, analysis, reasoning, problem solving, and some level of
      communication and collaboration with their peers.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="laboratory">
          <title>Laboratory</title>
          <p>For the laboratory instructions, we suggested that instead of
      including introductory explanations that mimicked what was
      previously discussed in lecture, to instead include questions that
      students would be required to think about and connect with the
      lecture material. We also advised the instructor to provide
      opportunities for the students to record observations, respond to
      questions, and make connections throughout the laboratory
      experience as opposed to only including questions at the end. For
      example, we pointed out that although the questions at the end of
      the ‘circulation lab’ were worded effectively, they would have
      been more valuable if asked throughout the various sections of the
      lab handout rather than all at the end or if in the form of
      concluding questions aimed at analyzing the results and writing a
      summary about the impact of the various factors on blood pressure.
      As was the case with the homework assignment instructions
      handouts, it was suggested that the instructor should include
      higher level, open-ended, critical thinking and analysis questions
      that would enable students to think more in-depth about the
      addressed content. Below is an excerpt of one of our suggestions
      on the ‘germs’ lab:</p>
          <disp-quote>
            <p>The lab report questions should be asked as students complete
        the steps and not as an afterthought. So, first have them think
        about the question and hypothesis. Then, have them read through
        the procedures and summarize what they are asked to do in the
        lab write-up, and then have them collect data and graph it and
        finally draw conclusions. When the lab report components are
        included at the very end, students will often just do the
        procedure without much thinking.</p>
          </disp-quote>
          <p>Furthermore, it was suggested that the instructor ought to
      avoid providing information on possible or expected observations
      or results and instead allow students to make their own
      observations, gather and analyze their findings, and then make the
      necessary connection to lecture material by explaining if and how
      their observations aligned or related to the content discussed.
      For instance, for the ‘cells’ lab, we pointed out that students
      should be asked questions about the various cell organelles, such
      as chloroplasts or vacuoles, rather than being given information
      about them. We also indicated that the task instructions for each
      station should be void of any reference to what students may
      actually observe in terms of the cell structures and instead ask
      them to draw and describe their observations and then make
      connections to the lecture or other resources to explain their
      observations.</p>
          <p>Finally, similar to the lecture component, we emphasized the
      importance of focusing on the process of scientific inquiry,
      especially in the laboratory, which more considerably involves
      ‘doing’ science. It was suggested that student experiences in the
      laboratory should more closely reflect the various aspects of the
      interwoven and cyclical process of scientific inquiry. As part of
      this, we recommended that laboratory sessions, such as the ‘cells’
      and ‘DNA’ labs, that were more in line with descriptive or
      comparative investigations be highlighted as such and emphasized
      just as important as laboratory investigations that involve
      setting up controlled experiments. For experimental
      investigations, we recommended that students be required to be
      cognizant of the scientific process they were involved with in
      various contexts and asked to identify the question of inquiry,
      the hypothesis, the different variables, and, when appropriate,
      even plan the investigation with respect to the control and
      experimental groups. For example, for the ‘germs’ lab, we
      suggested that students be instructed to identify the independent,
      dependent, and controlled variables or set up. Similarly, for the
      ‘circulation’ lab, we recommended having students think about the
      investigation question and hypothesis and identify the various
      components of the investigation, such as the different variables,
      as they proceed with the lab.</p>
        </sec>
      </sec>
      <sec id="post-observations">
        <title>Post Observations</title>
        <p>During the second round of observations, we identified a number
    of changes that had been made by the instructor to address
    previously discussed feedback. However, we agreed to continue the
    discussion and revision process by having her continue to reflect
    and inquire about questions or areas she needed further assistance
    or clarification and for us to provide additional ongoing
    suggestions and support to assist in further improving the course.
    The revisions made and areas still requiring further modification
    are discussed below and summarized in <bold><xref ref-type="table" rid="table-18">Table 2</xref></bold>.</p>
        <sec id="lecture-sessions-1">
          <title>Lecture sessions</title>
          <p>During the second iteration of teaching the course, the
      instructor continued to incorporate brief animations and
      videoclips that served as effective visuals and supporting
      resources during the lecture. For example, she showed a videoclip
      demonstrating how the heart works, another one showing the vocal
      cords in action during singing, and another one about eating
      lemons as part of digestion. She also incorporated engaging and
      relevant real-life examples and made connections with previously
      addressed concepts or students’ prior experiences. Examples
      included the discussions of possible reasons for vomiting, the
      history of lactose intolerance, the existence of battery acid in
      the stomach, reaction to ‘delicious’ versus ‘yucky/tasteless’ food
      and reasons for picky eating, and the connection between breathing
      at high altitudes and red blood cell counts with the use of a
      special mask, and the Lance Armstrong controversy.</p>
          <p>Additionally, she began to incorporate brief, yet engaging,
      demonstrations and team tasks that created more opportunities for
      students to become interested and intrigued in the subject matter
      as well as actively involved in the exploration, close
      examination, and discussion of the concepts being addressed.
      Demonstrations included the helium inhaling demo followed by
      questions and discussion that students found interesting and
      intriguing. In discussing the larynx, students engaged in a brief
      task during which they attempted to say something while feeling
      their voice box, which got them engaged and sharing observations.
      In another example, the students did a quick pretzel eating task
      simulating the chewing and swallowing mechanisms, which was
      effective at engaging student interest and initiated
      discussion.</p>
          <p>Finally, another important added component to the lectures was
      the incorporation of more frequent and engaging discussions and
      critical thinking questions for some of the topics. Examples
      included the questions and discussion about possible activities
      that alter the heartrate as an introduction to the heart’s
      function, discussion question at the end of the respiration
      lecture about why athletes go to high altitudes for training, use
      of engaging image about damage to the heart followed by effective
      discussion about the impact of drinking and the connection with
      arteries, veins, and high blood pressure, as well as the effective
      questions and discussion about the role of the villi after sharing
      a brief example of the baby born without any villi.</p>
          <p>Although there were some attempts to modify the lecture
      session, we discussed several additional changes that we deemed
      necessary or requiring further attention. For example, the
      beginning of most lecture sessions remained predominantly teacher
      directed and consisted of a simple and quick review and
      re-explanation of previously discussed material. We suggested that
      the review be done by engaging students in thinking about the
      material through questions and class discussion, which would also
      allow for assessing student understanding, confusions, and ability
      to make connections and apply the content.</p>
          <p>Furthermore, other than the inclusion of occasional examples or
      scenarios, there were no attempts to use cases, scenarios, and
      problems/challenges and focusing essential questions to initiate a
      topic, provide context, set the stage, engage the students, and
      explore and discuss the content. Finally, on several occasions,
      there were examples or references, which may not have been
      familiar or relevant for some students. We discussed the need to
      consider students’ prior experiences and familiarity, interests,
      challenges, limitations, and what they may find appropriate and
      avoid or clarify examples that they may not be familiar with or
      find inappropriate or unapplicable to them. For example, in one
      session, the Olympic game question about the athlete who had a
      certain blood condition was a valuable question; however, it would
      be engaging and suitable only if students are familiar with the
      particular winter Olympic game mentioned. We suggested that in
      such cases, playing a brief videoclip or showing an image or
      having students do a quick search on their digital devices would
      allow a certain level of exposure necessary before they can
      consider the question. In another similar case, the example of
      overdrinking or experiencing a hangover may either be
      inappropriate or not apply to all students who either do not
      engage in drinking or may have not experienced getting drunk or
      having a hangover.</p>
          <p>Moreover, there were some lecture sessions that remained,
      either partially or completely, continuous instructor lecture with
      few to no questions or discussions in between. Examples included
      the cardiac lecture consisting of the coverage of content related
      to aneurysm and hemorrhage without any questions and the digestion
      lecture and the coverage of information about how food travels
      through the digestive system. The blood type discussion about the
      role of the receptors as well as the questions about the Rh
      factors and blood transfusion should have been done as team
      discussions and brief tasks instead of teacher-led
      discussions.</p>
          <p>We recommended maximizing student engagement through the
      inclusion of more frequent questions, discussions, and brief
      collaborative tasks, to engage students in or at least allow them
      to be aware of the process of scientific inquiry. The timing and
      order or sequence of some of the questions, discussions, or quick
      tasks interspersed in various lecture sessions needs to be
      reconsidered to allow for maximum engagement, student thinking,
      and discussion and connection prior to the formal introduction of
      concepts. For example, during the circulation lecture, the
      instructor posed an effective question about fear and heartrate
      and had students pay attention to their heart rate as they watched
      a scene from a scary movie scene. However, she did so after her
      full explanation about the role of adrenaline and full description
      of the film scene, which minimized the suspense and surprise
      effect. Instead, she should have started with the movie clip and
      task of monitoring their heart rate in order to capture students’
      attention, pique their curiosity, and allow them to have
      experienced the fear, suspense, and heart rate increase themselves
      before discussing and introducing the content. In another
      instance, during the discussion about the genetics of hemophilia,
      the instructor first thoroughly explained genetic pedigrees and
      provided detailed information about who would be carriers or get
      the trait or disease rather than starting with students examining
      a sample pedigree and analyzing it for any patterns and possible
      explanations. During another session, the ‘too much of a good
      thing’ slide about the consequences of high levels of white blood
      cells was covered quickly by the instructor, whereas it should
      have instead been done by asking students to discuss what they
      noticed in the image and their thoughts about the possible
      consequences of too many white blood cells based on what they had
      previously learned about red blood cells.</p>
          <p>Finally, in conjunction with the abovementioned observations
      and recommendations, we suggested more opportunities for student
      cooperation, collaboration, and discussion with their peers.
      Students often sat in individual seats and were never assigned to
      teams and seldom asked to work in groups. We discussed the need to
      either assign teams of two-four students or encourage sitting next
      to and working as a team with different students during each
      session to complete tasks and engage in discussions. During some
      of the sessions, class discussions were limited to only one or a
      few students responding to questions while others remained silent.
      We reemphasized the importance of engaging more students and
      introduced the instructor to the idea of ‘wait time’ when asking
      questions to allow more students to have a chance to think about
      the questions and be willing to raise their hand to respond to the
      questions as well as encourage other students to follow up with
      additional thoughts and ideas or to indicate their agreement or
      disagreement with the earlier responses. This would allow for
      productive dialogue as opposed to simply asking discrete
      questions. Furthermore, we highlighted the need to refrain from
      statements such as ‘that’s the correct answer I was looking for’
      or quickly accepting an ‘accurate’ response and proceeding to the
      next question or discussion of content because such actions
      emphasize the need to provide ‘correct answers’ rather than
      attempt to think critically and creatively and generate potential
      ideas.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="homework-2">
          <title>Homework</title>
          <p>The instructor made a noticeable and concerted effort to modify
      the homework assignments by using relevant text, cases, and
      scenarios for students to read, analyze, and critically think
      about in light of material discussed in lecture. The revised
      homework tasks allowed students to realize the real-life context
      and relevancy of the material learned in the lecture and be able
      to think critically, apply their understanding, problem solve, as
      well as read and communicate effectively and reflectively. For
      instance, she created a case study homework assignment on osmosis,
      which related directly to the material discussed in lecture and
      required application of lecture material by thinking about a
      scenario about a woman who suffered a fatal case of water
      intoxication after entering a radio station contest. The
      instructor also developed similar case study assignments on
      radon’s impacts on the lungs and the effects of nicotine on
      circulation. Early in the semester, she made extensive changes to
      an existing homework assignment focusing on the Tuskegee Syphilis
      Experiment. She provided students with the background on the
      origins and history of syphilis and included questions from
      another existing case study in order to engage the students and
      initiate their thinking before they watched a documentary film on
      the topic.</p>
          <p>We only made a couple of minor suggestions for further
      improvements with respect to the homework assignments. First, we
      recommended possibly incorporating some of the questions,
      scenarios, or problems provided as part of the homework
      assignments into the lecture sessions to allow for discussion and
      exchange of ideas among students. To allow for some of the
      homework assignments to be more reflective or involve in-depth
      critical thinking, we suggested using the course discussion forum
      to allow students to post their responses and thoughts and be able
      to read and respond to their peers’ posts. This would perhaps
      allow them to engage in further discussion and critical thinking
      and enhance their communication skills in the process.</p>
        </sec>
        <sec id="laboratory-sessions-1">
          <title>Laboratory sessions</title>
          <p>Several changes were made to some of the laboratory sessions.
      All the revised laboratory instructions incorporated questions for
      students to think about and respond to throughout the handout as
      opposed to only at the end. For at least some of the laboratory
      sessions, the instructions included more open-ended questions,
      effective connection to the scientific inquiry model, and use of
      real-life and relevant examples and framework to contextualize
      scientific investigations. For example, in the case of both the
      ‘DNA’ and ‘germs’ laboratory sessions, the instructor inserted
      effective questions throughout the handout and made clear
      connection to the scientific inquiry model. The ‘nervous system’
      lab incorporated multiple activities that were effective both in
      terms of the instructions included as well as the incorporation of
      questions throughout the handout for students to think about,
      discuss, and respond to. Finally, the revised ‘termites’ lab
      provided a real life, relevant context about termite damage to
      buildings to contextualize the scientific investigation students
      were to embark on.</p>
          <p>The main suggestion we made on the laboratory component of the
      course was for the instructor to reword and replace some of the
      remaining closed-ended questions with more open-ended ones. We
      reminded her to avoid yes/no or one-to-two-word response types of
      questions such as ‘do you think …?’ or ‘Does the …?’, which tend
      to not allow students to think in-depth or explain their responses
      thoroughly. Instead, we recommended such questions be re-worded
      into open-ended questions, such as ‘how would you describe….?’,
      ‘explain whether or not …’, ‘compare and contrast the …’, that
      provide students the opportunity to think and process the
      questions and the content more deeply and more thoroughly explain
      their thoughts and observations.</p>
        </sec>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="discussion">
      <title>DISCUSSION</title>
      <p>The current action research has proved to be an enlightening
  process that has enabled us to utilize a collaborative approach to
  explore, reflect upon, and improve the course focus and instructional
  practices. With just one round of full professional development and
  continual feedback the instructor was able to successfully initiate
  changes in the course.</p>
      <p>The modifications were most evident in the homework assignments and
  the laboratory instructions handouts. The lecture sessions were
  slightly modified but there remained a number of issues that still
  require further attention and modification, including student
  evaluation and engaging students in collaborative tasks. There may be
  a number of possible reasons for the lack of more extensive changes,
  particularly with the lecture component, which consisted of the least
  modification. This may have partially been due to the fact that it
  involved the instructor’s real-time actions, instructional decisions,
  and interactions with students, which are more difficult and
  challenging to revise. Such changes require time for advance planning,
  practice with implementation, continual self-reflection, and
  collaborative support. This is line with what has been reported in the
  literature. One of the main factors cited by science faculty for not
  implementing changes in their courses and adopting inquiry-based
  instructional approach is the lack of time to devote to making the
  necessary changes, implementing them, and evaluating them for the need
  for further revisions (Brownell &amp; Tanner, 2012). Additionally, the
  literature on instructor’s adoption of reform-based instructional
  approaches have further identified difficulty in convincing science
  faculty of the potential ineffectiveness of their teaching practices,
  which they have adopted based on their own academic experiences
  (Brownell &amp; Tanner, 2012). This did not hold completely true for
  the course instructor in this study who expressed eagerness to engage
  in the collaborative professional development experience and becoming
  acquainted with effective and research-based strategies. However, she
  may have inadvertently, reverted to more traditional approaches at
  times, perhaps due to time limitation, insufficient practice with
  effective approaches, or lack of comfort and confidence in fully
  adopting these approaches, as suggested by previous studies (Hativa,
  1995; Hanson &amp; Moser, 2003; Luft et al., 2004; Yarnall et al.,
  2007).</p>
      <p>Prior studies (e.g., Dancy et al., 2016; Smith et al., 2009; Stains
  &amp; Vickrey, 2017) have indicated that instructors may implement
  research-based strategies differently than intended, which will
  consequently impact student learning in a significant manner. To
  address the issue with science faculty’s limited pedagogical
  knowledge, it is imperative to provide them ongoing professional
  development and continuing and iterative opportunities to apply and
  practice what they learn and evaluate the efficacy of the new
  approaches when implemented in the classroom (AAAS, 2009). At this
  time, this course instructor’s revision of her course has only been
  evaluated once. It is expected that, having experienced the first
  round of revising and teaching the course and receiving the in-depth
  feedback the subsequent iterations of the course are bound to include
  more comprehensive improvements. Because action research is an ongoing
  cycle, what we learn from the process will be utilized to continue the
  process of exploration, reflection, and improvement. In another
  article (in review), we focus on the instructor’s initial and evolving
  beliefs about science and science teaching, motivation to embark on a
  professional development and course revision, ongoing reflections on
  the professional development and course modification experiences, and
  barriers and concerns impeding possible changes in her instructional
  practice. Prior studies have indicated that active and interactive
  engagement of students in tasks that result in deeper cognitive and
  collaborative learning as opposed to a passive and disengaged learning
  process in the traditional approach (Arthurs &amp; Kreager, 2017; Chi,
  2009; Chi &amp; Wylie, 2014; Freeman et al., 2014). Future studies are
  necessary to explore the students’ perspective and experiences in a
  course that has been revised to include active student engagement
  strategies and to examine the impact of such instruction on students’
  understanding of content, attitudes, and beliefs about science.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="conclusions">
      <title>CONCLUSIONS</title>
      <p>Over the past few decades, there have been numerous calls for
  undergraduate science courses to adopt instructional approaches
  incorporating student-centered and active learning experiences that
  allow for greater student engagement in the learning process and
  higher order thinking (Donovan &amp; Bransford, 2005; Freeman et al.,
  2014). The current study aimed to address a gap in the literature that
  is considerably devoid of studies focusing on the effects of the
  professional development experience on the faculty member’s
  instructional behaviors and decisions and lack of reporting on the
  nature and extent of revisions and modifications that are made to such
  courses. In sharing the collaborative action research process we
  embarked on, we hope that our reflections and the project findings may
  be insightful for other science educators and individuals responsible
  for teaching undergraduate science content courses. It is critical to
  continue exploring efforts to reform undergraduate science courses. It
  is equally essential to employ multiple and varied investigative
  approaches examining various components such as instructor beliefs and
  attitudes, instructional approach and motivation to change, changes in
  student beliefs, attitude, and understanding as a result of revised
  instructional approaches, and more. Conducting action research studies
  such as this one and disseminating the findings and lessons learned
  yield multiple potential benefits. On a more personal and individual
  level for the instructors, such action research allows for a unique
  opportunity for self-reflection and introspection, engagement in
  collaboration and professional development with science and STEM
  education professionals, and the experience of adopting research-based
  instructional practices. Additionally, there is a considerable added
  value of providing a unique context for merging theoretical research
  and instructional practice through the collaborative and recursive
  process of reflection, professional development, implementation,
  discussion, supportive coaching, modification, and so forth. This
  study will be of major interest and relevance to U.S. and
  international science educators and researchers interested in issues
  related to undergraduate science education and faculty professional
  development.</p>
      <p>
        <bold>Author contributions:</bold> All authors have sufficiently
  contributed to the study and agreed with the results and
  conclusions.</p>
      <p>
        <bold>Funding:</bold> No funding source is reported for this
  study.</p>
      <p>
        <bold>Ethical statement:</bold> The authors stated that the study
  did not involve any samples or subjects and did not require an ethics
  committee approval. It is an analysis of the process the authors went
  through and the artifacts that they produced.</p>
      <p>
        <bold>Declaration of interest:</bold> No conflict of interest is
  declared by authors.</p>
      <p>
        <bold>Data sharing statement:</bold> Data supporting the findings
  and conclusions are available upon request from the corresponding
  author.</p>
    </sec>
  </body>
  <back>
    <ref-list>
      <title>References</title>
      <ref id="B-421896">
        <title>1</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>AAAS. (2009). Vision and change in undergraduate biology education: A
call to action. <italic>American Association for the Advancement of
Science</italic>.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://www.visionandchange.org/">http://www.visionandchange.org</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421897">
        <title>2</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Arthurs, L. A., &amp; Kreager, B. Z. (2017). An integrative review of
in-class activities that enable active learning in college science
classroom settings. <italic>International Journal of Science Education,
39</italic>(15), 2073-2091.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2017.1363925">https://doi.org/10.1080/09500693.2017.1363925</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421898">
        <title>3</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Baldwin, R. G. (2009). The climate for undergraduate teaching and
learning in STEM fields. <italic>New Directions for Teaching and
Learning, 2009</italic>(117), 9-17.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/tl.340">https://doi.org/10.1002/tl.340</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421899">
        <title>4</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Ballen, C. J., Wieman, C., Salehi, S., Searle, J. B., &amp; Zamudio,
K. R. (2017). Enhancing diversity in undergraduate science:
Self-efficacy drives performance gains with active learning.
<italic>CBE–Life Sciences Education,</italic> <italic>16</italic>(4),
ar56.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.16-12-0344">https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.16-12-0344</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421900">
        <title>5</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Barr, R. B., &amp; Tagg, J. (1995). From teaching to learning—A new
paradigm for undergraduate education. <italic>Change, 27</italic>(6),
13-25.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421901">
        <title>6</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Beichner, R. J., Saul, J. M., Abbott, D. S., Morse, J. J., Deardorff,
D. L., Allain, R. J., Bonham, S., Dancy, M. H., &amp; Risley, J. S.
(2007). Student-centered activities for large enrollment undergraduate
programs (SCALE-UP) project. In E. F. Redish, &amp; P. J. Cooney (Eds.),
<italic>Reviews in physics education research (PER): Research-based
reform in university physics</italic>. American Association of Physics
Teachers.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421902">
        <title>7</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Boyer Commission on Educating Undergraduates in the Research
University. (1998). Reinventing undergraduate education: A blueprint for
America’s research universities. <italic>State University of New York at
Stony Brook for the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of
Teaching</italic>.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED424840">http://eric.ed.gov/?id=ED424840</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421903">
        <title>8</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Brownell, S. E., &amp; Tanner, K. D. (2012). Barriers to faculty
pedagogical change: Lack of training, time, incentives, and tensions
with professional identity? <italic>CBE–Life Sciences Education,
11</italic>(4), 339-346.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.12-09-0163">https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.12-09-0163</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421904">
        <title>9</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Bybee, R. (1997). <italic>Achieving scientific literacy: From
purposes to practices</italic>. Heinemann Publications.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421905">
        <title>10</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Capobianco, B. M. (2007). Science teachers’ attempts at integrating
feminist pedagogy through collaborative action research. <italic>Journal
of Research in Science Teaching, 44</italic>(1), 1-32.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.20120">https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.20120</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421906">
        <title>11</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Carr, W., &amp; Kemmis, S. (1986). <italic>Becoming critical:
Education knowledge and action research</italic>. Routledge.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203496626">https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203496626</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421907">
        <title>12</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Chi, M. T. H. (2009). Active-constructive-interactive: A conceptual
framework for differentiating learning activities. <italic>Topics in
Cognitive Science, 1</italic>(1), 73-105.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1756-8765.2008.01005.x">https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1756-8765.2008.01005.x</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421908">
        <title>13</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Chi, M. T. H., &amp; Wylie, R. (2014). The ICAP framework: Linking
cognitive engagement to active learning outcomes. <italic>Educational
Psychologist, 49</italic>(4), 219-243.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2014.965823">https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2014.965823</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421909">
        <title>14</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Crouch, C. H., <italic>&amp;</italic> Mazur, E. (2001). Peer
instruction: Ten years of experience and results. <italic>American
Journal of Physics, 69</italic>(9), 970-977.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1119/1.1374249">https://doi.org/10.1119/1.1374249</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421910">
        <title>15</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Dancy, M., Henderson, C., &amp; Turpen, C. (2016). How faculty learn
about and implement research-based instructional strategies: The case of
peer instruction. <italic>Physical Review Physics Education Research,
12</italic>, 010110.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.12.010110">https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevPhysEducRes.12.010110</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421911">
        <title>16</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Donovan, M. S., &amp; Bransford, J. D. (2005). <italic>How students
learn–Science in the classroom</italic>. National Academy Press.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421912">
        <title>17</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Eddy, S. L., &amp; Hogan, K. A. (2014). Getting under the hood: how
and for whom does increasing course structure work? <italic>CBE–Life
Sciences Education, 13</italic>(3), 453-468.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.14-03-0050">https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.14-03-0050</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421913">
        <title>18</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Feldman, A., &amp; Minstrell, J. M. (2000). <italic>Action research
as a research methodology for the study of the teaching and learning of
science</italic>.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://people.umass.edu/~afeldman/ActionResearchPapers/FeldmanMinstrell2000.PDF">https://people.umass.edu/~afeldman/ActionResearchPapers/FeldmanMinstrell2000.PDF</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421914">
        <title>19</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Freeman, S., Eddy, S. L., McDonough, M., Smith, M. K., Okoroafor, N.,
Jordt, H., &amp; Wenderoth, M. P. (2014). Active learning increases
student performance in science, engineering, and mathematics.
<italic>PNAS, 111</italic>(23), 8410-8415.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1319030111">https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1319030111</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421915">
        <title>20</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Haak, D. C., HilleRisLambers, J., Pitre, E., &amp; Freeman, S.
(2011). Increased structure and active learning reduce the achievement
gap in introductory biology. <italic>Science, 332</italic>(6034),
1213-1216.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1204820">https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1204820</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421916">
        <title>21</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Hanson, S. C., &amp; Moser, S. C. (2003). Reflections on a
dscipline-wide Project: Developing active learning modules on the human
dimensions of global change. <italic>Journal of Geography in Higher
Education, 27</italic>(1), 17-38.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1080/0309826032000062441">https://doi.org/10.1080/0309826032000062441</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421917">
        <title>22</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Hativa, N. (1995). What is taught in an undergraduate lecture?
Differences between a matched pair of pure and applied disciplines.
<italic>New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 1995</italic>(64),
19-27.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/tl.37219956405">https://doi.org/10.1002/tl.37219956405</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421918">
        <title>23</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Kazempour, M., &amp; Amirshokoohi, A. (2013). Reforming an
undergraduate environmental science course for nonscience majors.
<italic>Journal of College Science Teaching, 43</italic>(2), 54-59.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://www.jstor.org/stable/43631072">http://www.jstor.org/stable/43631072</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421919">
        <title>24</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Loucks-Horsley, S., Hewson, P. W., Love, N., &amp; Stiles, K. E.
(1998). <italic>Designing professional development for teachers of
science and mathematics</italic>. Corwin Press.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421920">
        <title>25</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Luft, J. A., Kurdziel, J. P., Roehrig, G. H., &amp; Turner, J.
(2004). Growing a garden without water: Graduate teaching assistants in
introductory science laboratories at a doctoral/research university.
<italic>Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 41</italic>(3),
211-233.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.20004">https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.20004</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421921">
        <title>26</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>National Science Foundation. (1996). Shaping the future: New
expectations for undergraduate education in science, mathematics,
engineering, and technology: A report on its review of undergraduate
education by the Advisory Committee to the National Science Foundation,
Directorate for Education and Human Resources. <italic>National Science
Foundation</italic>.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://www.nsf.gov/pubs/1998/nsf98128/contents.pdf">https://www.nsf.gov/pubs/1998/nsf98128/contents.pdf</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421922">
        <title>27</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>NRC. (1996). <italic>From analysis to action: Undergraduate education
in science, mathematics, engineering, and technology</italic>. National
Academies Press.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.17226/9128">https://doi.org/10.17226/9128</ext-link>Top
of FormBottom of Form</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421923">
        <title>28</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>NRC. (1997). <italic>Science teacher preparation in an era of
standards-based reform</italic>. National Academies Press.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.17226/9078">https://doi.org/10.17226/9078</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421924">
        <title>29</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>NRC. (2003). <italic>BIO2010: Transforming undergraduate education
for future research biologists</italic>. National Academies Press.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.17226/10497">https://doi.org/10.17226/10497</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421925">
        <title>30</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Olson, S., &amp; Riordan, D. G. (2012). <italic>Engage to Excel:
Producing one million additional college graduates with degrees in
science, technology, engineering, and mathematics</italic>. Report to
the President. Executive Office of the President.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ostp/pcast-engage-to-excel-final_2-25-12.pdf">https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/sites/default/files/microsites/ostp/pcast-engage-to-excel-final_2-25-12.pdf</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421926">
        <title>31</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Seymour, E. (2002). Tracking the processes of change in US
undergraduate education in science, mathematics, engineering, and
technology. <italic>Science Education, 86</italic>(1), 79-105.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.1044">https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.1044</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421927">
        <title>32</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Siebert E. D., &amp; McIntosh W. J. (2001). <italic>College pathways
to the science education standards.</italic> NSTA Press.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421928">
        <title>33</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Smith, M. K., Wood, W. B., Adams, W. K., Wieman, C., Knight, J. L.,
Guild, N., &amp; Su, T. T. (2009). Why peer discussion improves student
performance on in-class concept questions. <italic>Science,
323</italic>(5910), 122-124.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1165919">https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1165919</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421929">
        <title>34</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Stains, M., &amp; Vickrey, T. (2017). Fidelity of implementation: An
overlooked yet critical construct to establish effectiveness of
evidence-based instructional practices. <italic>CBE–Life Sciences
Education, 16</italic>(1), rm1.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.16-03-0113">https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.16-03-0113</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421930">
        <title>35</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Theobald, E. J., Hill, M. J., Tran, E., Agrawal, S., Arroyo, E. N.,
Behling, S., Chambwe, N., Cintrón, D. L., Cooper, J. D., Dunster, G.,
Grummer, J. A., Hennessey, K., Hsiao, J., Iranon, N., Jones, L., Jordt,
H., Keller, M., Lacey, M. E., Littlefield, C. E., Lowe, A., …, &amp;
Freeman, S. (2020). Active learning narrows achievement gaps for
underrepresented students in undergraduate science, technology,
engineering, and math. <italic>PNAS, 117</italic>(12), 6476-6483.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1916903117">https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1916903117</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421931">
        <title>36</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Understanding Science. (2022). <italic>University of California
Museum of Paleontology</italic>.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="http://www.understandingscience.org/">http://www.understandingscience.org</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421932">
        <title>37</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>van Zee, E., Lay, D., &amp; Roberts, D. (2003). Fostering
collaborative inquiries by prospective and practicing elementary and
middle school teachers. <italic>Science Education, 87</italic>(4),
588-612.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.10070">https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.10070</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-421933">
        <title>38</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Yarnall, L., Toyama, Y., Gong, B., Ayers, C., &amp; Ostrander, J.
(2007). Adapting scenario-based curriculum materials to community
college technical courses. <italic>Community College Journal of Research
and Practice, 31</italic>(7), 583-601.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1080/10668920701428881">https://doi.org/10.1080/10668920701428881</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
    </ref-list>
    <sec sec-type="display-objects">
      <title>Figures and Tables</title>
      <fig id="figure-4509">
        <label>Figure 1</label>
        <caption>
          <p>Four phases of action research process (Source: Authors’ own
elaboration)</p>
</caption>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://www.ijese.com/figures/4509/figure1.png" />
      </fig>
      <fig id="figure-4510">
        <label>Figure 2</label>
        <caption>
          <p>Complex science flowchart depicts a detailed view of iterative
process of science (Understanding Science, 2022)</p>
</caption>
        <graphic xlink:href="https://www.ijese.com/figures/4510/figure2.png" />
      </fig>
      <table-wrap id="table-17">
        <label>Table 1</label>
        <caption>Key features of initial course components</caption>
        <table>
          <colgroup>
            <col width="50%" />
            <col width="50%" />
          </colgroup>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p>
                  <bold>Course components</bold>
                </p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>
                  <bold>Key
        features</bold>
                </p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p>Lecture</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Information-laden–Focus on
        coverage of content (product of science)</p>
                <p>Focused extensively on human biology content with little/no
        exposure or engagement in process of scientific inquiry</p>
                <p>Questions limited and for quick review of content</p>
                <p>Limited peer discussion and collaboration</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p>Homework</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Mainly simple, lower-level,
        close-ended questions/tasks</p>
                <p>Focused on information recall and knowledge of
        terminology</p>
                <p>No critical thinking, problem solving, analysis,
        communication</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td>
                <p>Laboratory</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Questions mainly included at
        end of handout</p>
                <p>Mainly simple, close-ended questions</p>
                <p>Information discussed in lecture re-explained on handout</p>
                <p>Inclusion of possible anticipated ‘observations’ or
        ‘results’</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
      <table-wrap id="table-18">
        <label>Table 2</label>
        <caption>Effective course revisions &amp; areas requiring improvement</caption>
        <table>
          <colgroup>
            <col width="33%" />
            <col width="33%" />
            <col width="33%" />
          </colgroup>
          <tbody>
            <tr>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p> </p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>
                  <bold>Revisions</bold>
                </p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>
                  <bold>Areas requiring
        improvement</bold>
                </p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Lecture</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Brief engaging demos &amp;
        tasks</p>
                <p>Helium inhaling</p>
                <p>Voice box singing</p>
                <p>Pretzel chewing and swallowing</p>
                <p>More frequent &amp; engaging discussions/questions for some
        topics</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Teacher directed quick
        reviews of previous material</p>
                <p>Few attempts to use cases, scenarios, &amp; focusing
        essential questions to initiate a topic or provide context</p>
                <p>Some sessions partially/completely teacher directed</p>
                <p>Student tasks followed instruction rather than being
        exploratory</p>
                <p>Limited opportunities for collaboration, communication, &amp;
        peer discussion</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Homework</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Use of relevant text, cases,
        &amp; scenarios</p>
                <p>Real-life connections</p>
                <p>Opportunities for critical thinking, problem-solving, &amp;
        application of content</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Use of discussion forum to
        improve peer collaboration</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
            <tr>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Laboratory</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Questions throughout the
        handout</p>
                <p>More open-ended questions</p>
                <p>Effective connection to scientific inquiry model</p>
                <p>Use of real life &amp; relevant examples as context for
        investigations</p>
                <p>Termite damage to buildings</p>
              </td>
              <td style="vertical-align: top">
                <p>Some close-ended
        questions</p>
              </td>
            </tr>
          </tbody>
        </table>
      </table-wrap>
    </sec>
  </back>
</article>