﻿<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<!DOCTYPE article PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.2 20190208//EN" "JATS-archivearticle1.dtd"[]>
<article xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink" dtd-version="1.2" article-type="research-article">
  <front>
    <journal-meta>
      <journal-id journal-id-type="publisher-id">ijese</journal-id>
      <journal-title-group>
        <journal-title>Interdisciplinary Journal of Environmental and Science
Education</journal-title>
      </journal-title-group>
      <issn publication-format="electronic">2633-6537</issn>
      <publisher>
        <publisher-name>Modestum</publisher-name>
      </publisher>
    </journal-meta>
    <article-meta>
      <article-id pub-id-type="doi">10.29333/ijese/17443</article-id>
      <title-group>
        <article-title>Regression from meaning? Ecological concepts as opaque
empty shells–Redux</article-title>
      </title-group>
      <contrib-group>
        <contrib contrib-type="author" corresp="yes">
          <contrib-id contrib-id-type="orcid">0000-0002-6276-2540</contrib-id>
          <name>
            <surname>Puk</surname>
            <given-names>Tom</given-names>
          </name>
          <email>tpuk@lakeheadu.ca</email>
          <xref ref-type="aff" rid="aff-1" />
          <xref ref-type="corresp" rid="cor-true">
            <sup>*</sup>
          </xref>
        </contrib>
        <aff id="aff-1">
          <label>1</label>
          <institution-wrap>
            <institution>Faculty of Education, Lakehead University, Thunder Bay, ON,
CANADA</institution>
          </institution-wrap>
        </aff>
      </contrib-group>
      <pub-date date-type="pub" publication-format="electronic" iso-8601-date="2025-11-19">
        <day>19</day>
        <month>11</month>
        <year>2025</year>
      </pub-date>
      <volume>21</volume>
      <issue>4</issue>
      <elocation-id>e2521</elocation-id>
      <permissions>
        <copyright-statement>Copyright © 2025 by Author/s and Licensed by
Modestum DOO, Serbia.</copyright-statement>
        <copyright-year>2025</copyright-year>
        <license license-type="open-access" xlink:href="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/">
          <license-p>This is an open access article distributed under the Creative
Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use,
distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work
is properly cited.</license-p>
        </license>
      </permissions>
      <abstract>
        <p>
In 2000 the Ontario Ministry of Education decided to integrate
environmental education into all subject areas rather than create a
distinct, compulsory subject area K-12 for ecological literacy. The
current study is a follow up to a 2010 study to determine whether the
ability of teacher-candidates to define key ecological concepts has
improved over the previous fifteen years while they were students during
the Ontario Ministry of Education’s policy of integration. The results
of the current study are very similar to that of the 2010 study. For the
concepts of the environment, sustainability, green, fossil fuels, and
entropy, there were no consistent shared definitions for any of these
concepts. Teacher-candidates appear to have quite varied understanding
of these concepts. The suggestion is made that the results of both
studies may indicate a “regression from meaning” and that for many
teacher-candidates the words they use often represent “opaque empty
shells.”
</p>
      </abstract>
      <kwd-group kwd-group-type="author">
        <kwd>meaning</kwd>
        <kwd>communication</kwd>
        <kwd>teachers</kwd>
        <kwd>education</kwd>
        <kwd>concepts</kwd>
        <kwd>ecology</kwd>
        <kwd>literacy</kwd>
      </kwd-group>
    </article-meta>
  </front>
  <body>
    <sec id="introduction">
      <title>INTRODUCTION</title>
      <disp-quote>
        <p>“When I [emphasis added] use a word, Humpty Dumpty said in rather
    a scornful tone, it just means what I choose it to mean–neither more
    nor less”
    (Lewis Carroll, 1871, Through the Looking Glass, p. 188).</p>
      </disp-quote>
      <p>Words, concepts, definitions, meaning. What is at the heart of
  understanding a topic? What is a definition and what role does it play
  in meaning-making? How should it be presented during instruction? What
  (if any) is the value of a definition? These are some of the questions
  that will be addressed in this paper as they apply in particular to
  K-12 and university education.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="background">
      <title>BACKGROUND</title>
      <p>In 2010, we conducted a study of preservice student understandings
  of specific ecological concepts (Puk &amp; Stibbards, 2010). This was
  a response to the Ontario Ministry of Education eliminating
  <italic>environmental science</italic> from the secondary curriculum
  in 1999 and 2000. This curriculum guideline was the main instrument
  that attempted to prepare teacher-candidates to teach their own
  eventual students about the human-nature relationship and the harm
  that human behavior was having on that relationship, presently and in
  the future. As a consequence of that action by the Ontario Ministry of
  Education, I and others attempted to advise the Ontario Ministry of
  Education that rather than eliminating this key subject area at a time
  of an increasing global concern about our human relationship and use
  of natural processes, that a comprehensive and compulsory new subject
  area of ecological literacy be created K-12. The Ontario Ministry of
  Education chose instead to “integrate” environmental education
  expectations (i.e., objectives) into other existing curriculum subject
  areas rather than creating a specific, discrete subject area. The goal
  of the 2010 study was to examine how successful the government’s
  “integration” policy was in creating ecologically literate graduates
  of the Ontario public school system.</p>
      <p>The 2010 study asked preservice students entering into an
  ecological and experiential education specialization to define
  specific concepts including the environment, sustainability and
  ‘green’ (as in, for example, green economy). These three words in
  particular were by then used regularly in media, textbooks and
  everyday language. Students’ prior knowledge has long been known to be
  a critical influence in acquiring an understanding of, in particular,
  scientific concepts. However, too often “there is an assumption that
  the terms are so widely used, everyone has a shared understanding of
  the terms” (Stichler, 2018, p. 6). Thus it is important to know what
  misconceptions (Suprapto, 2020) or alternative conceptions (Wandersee
  et al., 1994) students might have prior to instruction in order to
  bring about conceptual change through teaching/learning strategies
  that target these alternative conceptions (Henson, 1983). What the
  study uncovered was that there was no consistent, shared understanding
  of these often used words by teacher-candidates who were themselves
  graduates of the Ontario public school system and the integration
  policy. And that, in fact, these words were used by these students as
  if they were “opaque empty shells” (Puk &amp; Stibbards, 2010, p.
  461). Specifically, the words the teacher-candidates were effortlessly
  using in their everyday conversations were more like shells that
  prevented the receiver from looking through to determine what was
  meant by these words. When examined closely, they were empty of any
  specific, consistent, shared meaning (more on the specific findings of
  that study when I compare the present study with the 2010 one further
  in this paper).</p>
      <p>Thus, the current study is a fifteen year follow-up to the 2010
  study in order to determine whether or not graduates of the Ontario
  public school system, i.e., the now teacher-candidates, could define
  these concepts any more consistently than teacher-candidates fifteen
  years prior.</p>
      <p>What is different about the two studies is that the current one
  also involves Master of Education graduate students, all but one of
  whom are international students from India, China, Sri Lanka and
  Bangladesh. These students also defined the same concepts as the BEd
  teacher-candidates.</p>
      <p>However, we must first define what a concept and a definition are
  in order to understand what they do or should do. Podsakoff et al.
  (2016) described a concept as “cognitive symbols (or abstract terms)
  that specify the features, attributes, or characteristics of the
  phenomenon in the real or phenomenological world that they are meant
  to represent” (p. 161). As mental models, concepts are “personal and
  intrinsic representations of external reality the people build to make
  sense of the world” (Donmez &amp; Gulen, 2023, p. 57). I would add
  that a concept represents all of the features of the phenomenon in
  order to contrast it with the definition of a concept which is a
  concise statement describing the essence of the concept. “Concepts
  distill the entire set of observables into narrow, socially
  constructed groupings and categories” (Kamalova, 2023, p. 73).</p>
      <p>We can go back as far as Aristotle who described a definition as “a
  formula in words that tells us what the object of definition is”
  (Deslauriers, 2007, p. 1) and that it is fundamentally “a statement of
  essence” (Cassidy, 1967, p. 109). Today we might describe the essence
  of a concept as criterial attributes, the characteristics of an entity
  that makes it different from other entities. Robinson et al. (1985)
  described a definition as a mental structure that contains
  representations of the criterial attributes (i.e., the defining
  characteristics) of a class of things and of the rule that relates
  these elements to each other.</p>
      <p>Abbott (2002) argued that all departments of thought that are
  referred to as a discipline must be governed in turn by “a discipline
  of language” (p. i). Everyday language is most often not disciplined
  but uses words in a loose and indiscriminate manner, “talking ‘around’
  key terms rather than being precise” (Marr et al., 2021, p. 1092).
  This often leads to confusion with no definite outcomes (Abbott, 2002,
  p. ii). However the more complex the concept, for example
  biodiversity, the greater the need to have an adequate understanding
  of what it signifies as opposed to perhaps everyday language. Thus the
  purpose of a robust definition should be to provide some degree of
  discipline to discourse in order that a shared understanding of
  concepts may potentially lead to successful decision-making. Without
  this, we are often dependent on a perceptual interpretation of what we
  see or hear. It is also important to note that criterial attributes
  can be described using different words that have similar meanings.</p>
      <p>It is also important to distinguish between the concept, which
  exists as a mental model, from the concept name, for example
  government and the concept definition which might be described as an
  organized extraction of that mental model into external discourse.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="materials-and-methods">
      <title>MATERIALS AND METHODS</title>
      <p>The study of BEd teacher-candidates’ understanding of concepts
  involved three sections of the same course, Environmental Education in
  their final year of a two-year degree program taken after they had
  acquired their first university degree. Thus, they were in their sixth
  year of university. These three sections had a total enrollment of 98
  students. The graduate student definitions were administered to
  students in two different Master of Education courses, ‘ecological
  consciousness’ and ‘ecological integrity’, with a total enrollment of
  47. Thus, the complete study involved a maximum of 145 university
  students. In each course or section, definitions were collected over a
  period of two classes in order to not overwhelm the students at anyone
  sitting and not take up too much instructional class time. The author
  made sure that the specific definitions were administered prior to the
  concepts being introduced during the courses. Students were also
  required to turn off any electronic devices prior to writing their
  definitions on paper. Students were advised that they did not need to
  sign their names and that results had no bearing on their final course
  marks.</p>
      <sec id="concepts">
        <title>Concepts</title>
        <p>The concepts being defined were the same ones defined in the 2010
    study: the environment, sustainability, green (as in, for example,
    green energy, green economy), fossil fuels and entropy. The first
    four concepts are found either in Ontario Ministry of Education
    curriculum guidelines and/or teacher instruction, and/or textbooks
    as well as in media and everyday discourse. Entropy was chosen
    because it would be studied in the courses in which the
    teacher-candidates and graduate students would be enrolling.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="concept-analysis">
        <title>Concept Analysis</title>
        <p>For the purpose of making sure that the same parameters and
    practice were utilized and a fair comparison was made, the
    methodology used in the current study was also used in the 2010.
    This involved a qualitative content analysis (Graneheim &amp;
    Lundman, 2003) in order to interpret and code the definitions. As a
    form of discourse analysis, the written text of the participants was
    parsed and categorized in order to understand the mental
    representations the participants had (if any) for these
    concepts.</p>
        <p>The methodological sequence followed was such that: a/ the
    teacher-candidate was required to respond to the prompt for each
    concept, “what is it?”, in order to provide a definition that
    indicated their understanding of the concept in question. These
    written responses became the “units of analysis.” Any concepts that
    were not defined were coded as such at this stage; b/ content areas
    within each unit of analysis were then identified and then c/
    collapsed into “categories of meaning” and coded on the basis of</p>
        <list list-type="order">
          <list-item>
            <p>the number of similar and different criterial attributes
        and</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>the degree of vagueness in those attributes; d/ dominant
        themes were then formulated to signify “the thread of underlying
        meaning” found in each category (Puk &amp; Stibbards, 2010, p.
        464).</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
        <p>Discourse analysis is, by nature, subjective and always
    reflective of a degree of interpretation.</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="results">
      <title>RESULTS</title>
      <sec id="the-environment">
        <title>The Environment</title>
        <p>As in the 2010 study, three themes emerged from the data
    analysis. The dominant theme, as defined by 37.4 percent of the
    responses, described this concept as being the natural world
    only–involving trees, air, water, soil, etc.–but humans were not
    included in this theme. This was the most dominant theme in both the
    BEd responses (39.5%) and the MEd responses (33.3%). In the 2010
    study, the “natural world only” theme was also the dominant theme.
    In the current study, 22.9% of the responses stated that the
    environment was an “area” that involved a relationship between both
    humans and the natural world. Eighteen percent stated that the
    environment was the human “surroundings” that impact humans such as
    social relationships, education, health-care, etc. This is an older
    wording describing “one’s environment” rather than “the
    environment.”</p>
        <p>However the third largest category of responses at 21.3%
    represented vague wording that didn’t actually define the concept,
    for example one word responses such as “the atmosphere” and “mother
    nature.” The fact that there are three quite distinctly different
    themes and the fact that the second largest theme involved vague,
    non-definition responses, this author would argue, is because the
    wording itself is dysfunctional. The definite article “the”
    signifies the grammatical distinction that there is a definite place
    called the environment similar to the Atlantic Ocean, the Alps, the
    City of Beijing. Thus, many people think of the environment as being
    a physical space–the wilderness, lakes, trees–but not the urban area
    where they live. This thinking is found in everyday language of
    media, education, books, etc., which often refer to the environment
    as being distinctly separate from the economy, education and
    healthcare. It helps create an atomistic ontology in which there are
    separate, distinct categories of human existence rather than
    understanding that everything is interconnected; that economy,
    education, health-care and daily living, no matter what physical and
    geographical location an individual finds themselves in, is
    integrally intertwined with our relationship to natural processes.
    ‘They’ are really ‘one’. Unfortunately, little has changed in the
    discourse in the preceding fifteen years since the 2010 study.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="sustainabilitythe-humpty-dumpty-concept">
        <title>Sustainability–The Humpty Dumpty Concept</title>
        <p>This concept generated the most varied and distinctly different
    themes, even after collapsing a number of similar ones into a theme,
    with a total of 8! Thus, we might refer to it as the ‘Humpty Dumpty’
    concept (refer back to the opening lines of this study), i.e., “it
    means just what <italic>I</italic> [emphasis added] choose it to
    mean, neither more, nor less” (Lewis Carroll, 1871, p. 188).</p>
        <p>However, Alice’s response to Humpty Dumpty was, “the question is,
    said Alice, whether you <italic>can</italic> [emphasis added] make
    words mean so many different things” (Lewis Carroll, 1871, p.
    188).</p>
        <p>It is interesting to note that Lewis Carroll (i.e., Charles
    Dodgson) was an academic working in a university. As a
    mathematician, he may have been expressing his exasperation through
    the voice of Alice, with his perception of the undisciplined
    language of his time when he wrote these words. The eight themes for
    sustainability include:</p>
        <list list-type="order">
          <list-item>
            <p>keeping things the same,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>something we can reuse again in the future and it lasts a
        long time,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>choices with little to no effect on the environment,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>less negative effects on the environment,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>saving natural resources,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>related to survival on earth,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>perfect conditions with no bad changes, and</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>living within our means and avoiding errors.</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
        <p>The theme (2) with the highest number of individual responses at
    25% was “something we can reuse again in the future and lasts a long
    time.” Some of these themes, such as “perfect conditions with no bad
    changes” (2%), don’t represent anything remotely possible given
    earth’s geological history. However, the category that scored the
    highest was vague responses at 39%; almost four out of every 10
    responses! Examples of vague responses included “the act of
    conservating [sic]”, “reducing your means to be environmentally
    conscious” and “the way in which an environment is able to sustain
    and maintain progress and life.” Thus, not only is there no one
    dominant consistent definition of this word in the
    teacher-candidates’ minds, most didn’t have any kind of a
    definitional response. There was very little substance to the words
    students use. And there was also little difference in the total
    number of vague responses between the BEd (36.7%) and MEd (39%)
    students’ responses.</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="green">
        <title>Green</title>
        <p>There were five themes for this word:</p>
        <list list-type="order">
          <list-item>
            <p>less impact on the environment [presumably, less compared to
        non-green actions] and being mindful of the environment,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>actions that benefit the environment,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>healthier lifestyles,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>producing energy efficiently, and</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>a mental state of thinking about the environment.</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
        <p>An individual who thinks of green as involving healthier
    lifestyles and another who views green as producing energy
    efficiently, would appear to have very different meanings for this
    term. However, these five themes only represented 37 of 134 student
    responses! Ninety-seven responses (72.4%) were in the vague
    category. In other words, when listening to conversation that
    involves the word green, almost three-quarters of these students may
    have all kinds of disconnected, fleeting words swirling in their
    minds, yet most perhaps assume that their interpretation is similar
    to everyone else’s (more on this in the discussion section).
    Examples of vague responses included “something eco-friendly”,
    “being environmentally aware”, “alive”, and “nurturing.” There was
    little difference in the number of vague responses between the
    graduate responses (77%) and the teacher-candidate responses
    (71%).</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="fossil-fuels">
        <title>Fossil Fuels</title>
        <p>There were seven varied themes for fossil fuels:</p>
        <list list-type="order">
          <list-item>
            <p>carbon-based fuels made by natural processes over long
        periods of time (9 responses),</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>materials produced over long periods of time,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>provide energy from dead animals and plants,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>fossils from remains of creatures,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>chemicals for burning,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>energy that originates underground, and</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>energy from petroleum.</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
        <p>All seven of these themes represented 19% (44 of 142 responses)
    of the total responses. Non responses represented 7.7% of responses.
    The largest category by far was vague responses with 61.2% (87
    responses). Examples of vague responses included “biowaste of
    organisms and plants”, “cannot be recreated”, “non-renewable
    resource”, “coal that is burnt for energy”, “fuels from fossils.”
    Quite often examples of fossil fuels are given such as coal as the
    only response. However, examples are not definitions. They don’t
    tell us anything about the category of fossil fuels. It might seem
    surprising to the reader that a word that is in the common, almost
    daily vernacular of media and general public conversation, is so
    poorly understood. However, the results more importantly speak to
    the lack of disciplined language in the K-12 schooling and
    university degrees (more on this in the discussion section).</p>
      </sec>
      <sec id="entropy">
        <title>Entropy</title>
        <p>Once again, entropy produced the highest number of non-responses,
    i.e., 71.5% or 98 of 137 responses. This is very similar to the 2010
    study, when non-responses represented 73% of the total responses.
    However, there were also 23 (16.8%) vague responses in the current
    study. An example of a vague response was “heat” and “the principle
    of disorganization.” While these results are not unexpected, as this
    is a complex scientific topic, it is a critical concept in
    understanding one of the most fundamental forces that influences
    earthly existence as well as the universe. In addition, there were
    six themes from the few responses (16, 11.6%) that provided
    definitions. These varied themes included:</p>
        <list list-type="order">
          <list-item>
            <p>the rate of imbalance,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>rate of disorder,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>universal force that degrades energy,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>unavailability of thermal energy in the system,</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>chaos, chaotic energy, and</p>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>amount of disarray of a system.</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
      </sec>
      <sec id="summary-of-results">
        <title>Summary of Results</title>
        <p>After fifteen years since the 2010 study on concept development,
    the results are remarkably quite similar. There were no consistent,
    shared definitions for all five concepts provided by the
    teacher-candidates. In the responses that were provided, definitions
    were quite varied and, in many cases, opposite meanings were given.
    However, the largest category of responses in three of the five
    concepts were either vague, sustainability 39%; green 72.4%; fossil
    fuels 61.2%; or no definition was provided: entropy 71.5%.</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
    <sec id="discussion">
      <title>DISCUSSION</title>
      <list list-type="order">
        <list-item>
          <p>In the Ontario K-12 curriculum guidelines there are few
      comprehensive, consistent definitions of the concepts featured in
      this study, even though the words themselves are included.</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p>There is no specific focus nor value on the critical role that
  understanding definitions plays in meaning-making. There are no
  methodologies provided for teachers to emphasize concept development
  in these curriculum guidelines. There are no models for the
  self-directed development of concept definitions by students to help
  them explore for themselves the quality of meaning provided in the
  material they read or listen to in conversations (a more in-depth
  review on instruction of concepts can be found in Puk and Stibbards
  (2010, 2011, 2012) and Stibbards and Puk (2011).</p>
      <p>The grade 11 and grade 12 <italic>science curriculum
  guidelines</italic> document (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2008)
  does list fundamental concepts to be taught in the two environmental
  science courses. However, in the specific expectations (i.e.,
  objectives) for each course, there is no mention of acquiring
  definitions for these and other concepts included. Instead, a few
  specific expectations state that by the end of the course, students
  will “use appropriate terminology”, e.g., “relating to the
  environmental impact of human activity, including but not limited to
  carbon footprint, carbon neutral, biodegradable, biodiversity,
  carrying capacity, sustainability, and invasive and native species”
  (p. 168), etc. However, appropriate terminology can be easily
  <bold>used</bold> in any scenario without understanding what the
  concept <bold>means</bold>. There is no emphasis in the Ontario
  curriculum guidelines on defining the criterial attributes of, for
  example, “biodiversity” and “sustainability.”</p>
      <p>Similarly, in the <italic>geography curriculum guidelines</italic>
  (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2013) expectations state, for example,
  that students should “use the concepts of geographic thinking when
  analyzing and evaluating data and information, formulating conclusions
  and making judgments” (p. 72), and “apply the concepts of geographic
  thinking when analyzing current events” (p. 73). Once again, one can
  “use” concepts and “apply” concepts without necessarily knowing what
  they <bold>mean</bold>.</p>
      <p>However, in the previous set of <italic>environmental science
  curriculum guidelines</italic> (Ontario Ministry of Education, 1988),
  requiring students to define key concepts was a requirement in most
  curriculum units, e.g., “explain the meaning of the terms aerosol,
  dust and mist”; “describe the meaning of threshold limit value” (p.
  43); “explain the meaning of the terms pollination and in-line
  meaning” (p. 45). An emphasis on concept meanings eroded in the series
  of curriculum guidelines from 2000 to the present. It is important to
  note that the three concepts of the environment, sustainability and
  green did not exist at that time of the 1988 curriculum
  guidelines!</p>
      <list list-type="order">
        <list-item>
          <label>2.</label>
          <p>As stated earlier, rather than creating a distinct curriculum
      guideline for ecological literacy, K-12, as was recommended by
      many advocates, the Ontario Ministry of Education chose instead to
      ‘integrate’ environmental education into all courses K-12.</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p>After the 2010 study (Puk &amp; Stibbards, 2010), the Ontario
  Ministry of Education produced two documents called
  <italic>Environmental education scope and sequence of expectations,
  grades 9-12</italic>. <italic>A resource guide</italic> (2017a) and
  <italic>Environmental education scope and sequence of expectations,
  grades 1-8 and the kindergarten program</italic>. <italic>A resource
  guide</italic> (2017b).</p>
      <p>As is stated in both documents,</p>
      <disp-quote>
        <p>“... the Ministry of Education has ensured that environmental
    education is included in all grades and in all subjects of the
    Ontario curriculum, as appropriate … The scope and sequence resource
    guides for kindergarten to grade 8 and grades 9 to 12 identify these
    embedded expectations with the aim of assisting teachers in bringing
    environmental education into the classroom and every subject area
    and discipline” (Ontario Ministry of Education, 2017b, p. 3).</p>
      </disp-quote>
      <p>On the surface this might appear to be an effective policy.
  However, it is important to note that these documents are resource
  guides, not curriculum guidelines. Secondly, the expectations in these
  documents were taken from each existing curriculum guideline in each
  subject area. There is no environmental education curriculum
  guideline! These expectations are simply sprinkled as content into
  biology, physics, mathematics, etc.</p>
      <list list-type="order">
        <list-item>
          <label>3.</label>
          <p>Regression from meaning: Vague or non-responses</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p>The first three concepts of the environment, sustainability and
  green were used extensively in defining each of the other two
  concepts. They have become the ‘mean’ in this and the 2010 study that
  the teacher-candidates use in defining each concept, and no doubt in
  their conversations. For the sustainability responses, the terms such
  as “to sustain”, “green”, “environmental effect”, “environmental
  consciousness”, “the environment”, and “environmental” were used in
  the definitions for sustainability 34% of the time (i.e., 45 out of
  132 responses). Rather than using criterial attributes that might be
  distinct to this concept, variations of environmental and green were
  used instead. For green, terms such as “environmentally friendly”, “no
  harm to the environment”, “environmentally aware”, “living positive
  for the environment”, “sustainable”, “environmental consciousness”,
  and “sustainability”, were used 53.7% of the time (i.e., 72 responses
  out of 134 total responses). These three words have become the
  mainstay in the teacher-candidates’ discourse, representing a form of
  “ecological linguistic reductionism” (Puk &amp; Stibbards, 2010, p.
  472).</p>
      <list list-type="order">
        <list-item>
          <label>4.</label>
          <p>Regression from meaning: The source</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p>Regression from meaning involves moving away from the value and
  practice of ensuring in-depth understanding of the concepts we use to
  shallow, surface level meaning-making. The user becomes
  disenfranchised from meaning-making. The limitation with these three
  concepts as the mainstay in general discourse is that not only are
  there no consistently shared definitions for these terms, there was
  also a significant number of vague responses (i.e., responses that did
  not contain criterial attributes) and a significant number of non
  responses (i.e., no firm understanding of the concepts). The
  implication of this phenomenon in both the current study and the 2010
  study is that when we ask teacher-candidates to solidify and
  externalize what meaning they have for these concepts, we find that
  the words they use are like opaque shells that we can’t see through to
  determine if the user has a firm understanding of the words they are
  using. Invoking the words the environment, sustainability, or green by
  the user may obfuscate a lack of knowing to the receiver. The
  opaqueness protects the user from being exposed and, in reverse,
  exponentially provides the user with a patina of appearing to be
  articulate. Only when we ask the user to define the words that they
  use continuously do we find that those shells, i.e., words, are in
  fact often empty of meaning. They serve as opaque empty shells.</p>
      <p>However, we must keep in mind one critical point about these two
  studies. BEd and MEd students are products of their schooling! In
  regard to the BEd students, they have experienced at least fourteen
  years of public education interacting with Ministry of Education
  curriculum guidelines (as reviewed above), and another four years of
  Ontario university education in their first degree. The results are
  not the fault of the students, they are simply products of their
  schooling.</p>
      <p>One example of regression from meaning might be found in one
  university’s notion of definitions. A “survey to guide sustainability
  priorities and plan” sent out to the university’s community, states
  the following:</p>
      <disp-quote>
        <p>“Defining sustainability–for the purpose of this survey,
    sustainability is considered in a pluralistic and inclusive way,
    encompassing human and ecological health, social justice and equity,
    Indigenous rights, secure livelihoods, workplace well-being, and
    leadership for vibrant communities. It is a complex term as its
    meaning can differ from place to place and from person to person”
    (Office of Sustainability, 2025).</p>
      </disp-quote>
      <p>The implication is that because sustainability is a “complex term”,
  no definition is possible nor required. Rather, we should allow each
  person to create their own meaning from simply the name. More
  specifically, there is no need for disciplined language. To follow
  this logic we shouldn’t bother to define photosynthesis or entropy or
  diversity, or the difference between equity and equality, etc.,
  because these are complex terms and they mean different things to
  people in different places. However, as Glavic and Lukman (2007)
  concluded about the sustainability field, “the multitude of
  definitions causes much confusion about their usage, since the meaning
  of some terms is either sloppy or similar, or is only slightly
  different from one another” (p. 1875).</p>
      <p>As Donmez and Gulen (2023) emphasize, “how models of concepts are
  developed in the minds of students in a classroom environment and in
  higher education is an important question” (p. 58). It is even more
  important to realize that teacher-candidates will potentially be
  instructing their own students. The 2010 study and the current one
  suggest that if teacher-candidates don’t have a firm understanding of
  key concepts, they may eventually be limited in their ability to teach
  such concepts to their students. “Pre-service teachers who have more
  content knowledge tend to help students more to construct
  scientifically accepted knowledge” (Puk &amp; Stibbards, 2010, p.
  58).</p>
      <p>We should not forget that language influences perception. We might
  respond to the implication made in the university statement above with
  something Galileo is reported to have said about concepts and
  meaning-making: “Names and attributes must be accommodated to the
  essence of things, and not the essence to the names, since things come
  first and names afterward” (Drake, 1957, p. 92). This might remind us
  of the need for a disciplined correspondence between the name of a
  concept and the underlying essence/criterial attributes of that
  concept; and that deriving the emphasis of the underlying
  essence/meaning should always be the priority rather than an emphasis
  on the name. Effective communications between people require us to
  clearly express the underlying essence of a concept that is being
  shared.</p>
      <list list-type="order">
        <list-item>
          <label>5.</label>
          <p>Concept definitions as the initial stage to deep learning</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p>It is important to emphasize that concept definitions provide an
  initial stage of understanding of the meaning within the concept. They
  provide a solid starting point to effective meaning-making. But
  knowing and understanding the concept definition is not the end-point
  to meaning-making. As Robinson et al. (1985) and Puk (2024a) have
  indicated, further stages of a thorough elaboration of a concept would
  include conceptual model building, comparison, correlational, causal,
  decision-making and design provide increasing depth and “elaboration”
  of understanding after each successive stage. A seed eventually ends
  up as a plant. It is the critical first stage. The mature plant can’t
  exist without that first stage. Concept development proceeds in a
  similar manner. However unlike the seed/plant analogy,
  misunderstanding of a topic can proceed without first acquiring the
  meaning of words. This misunderstanding, based on faulty, immature
  assumptions will often lead to erroneous conclusions, and misdirected
  and disconnected action.</p>
      <list list-type="order">
        <list-item>
          <label>6.</label>
          <p>Progression in meaning: How should definitions be presented
      through instruction?</p>
        </list-item>
      </list>
      <p>Vygotsky (1987) had a particular affinity for definitions. “To
  Vygotsky, word meaning is the appropriate unit of analysis for
  studying the development of consciousness, which he equates with the
  development of concepts … People reveal the degrees of abstraction
  that they have achieved in their thinking” (Smagorinsky et al., 2016,
  pp. 1401-1402). This latter point is crucial to understanding what
  degrees of abstraction teacher-candidates have for key ecological
  concepts. However, Vygotsky also believed that teaching scientific
  concept (also interpreted as “academic” concepts, Smagorinsky et al.,
  2016, p. 1403) definitions in isolation through what he referred to as
  “direct instruction” was “fruitless” (p. 170), resulting in learning
  the word rather than the concept. Instead, the learner needs to
  connect a concept definition to the external world through a
  combination of formal instruction, experience, reflection and
  practice, integrating it through mindful activity. “A modern theory of
  conceptual change framework suggests that students need to increase,
  re-categorize and reorganize their cognitive structures to reach a
  more scientific understanding” (Donmez &amp; Gulen, 2023, p. 57).
  Vygotsky (1987) described this process as a “twisting path” (p. 156),
  as it takes more than just memorizing the words in an academic
  definition in order to fully internalize and understand it.</p>
      <p>In regard to the teacher-candidates in this study, once the
  definitional responses have been collected, the author teaches the
  definitions through “ecological macro-models” (Puk, 2021, 2023, 2024b,
  2025; Stibbards &amp; Puk, 2011). They experience the concept in
  natural surroundings through experiential learning. Ecological macro
  models are analogous activities during which the participant (i.e.,
  teacher-candidate) plays a component of the concept. For example, in
  the activity for biodiversity, the macro model is conducted in a treed
  area on campus. A student is either a potoroo, truffle, eucalyptus
  tree, bacterium or human. Each student is assigned to one of these
  organisms, designated by colored t-shirts. The four non-human
  organisms must find each other in the treed area and form a foursome
  representing a biodiverse ecosystem in Australia. When they do so they
  then hold onto the same rope as they move through the area trying to
  stay away from humans. Humans chase these other organisms and, if
  caught, they are led to the outside parameters of the playing area.
  This displacement of an organism signifies a weakening and potential
  loss of biodiversity. Two other roles of disease and fire also cause
  disruptions as they chase all the different organisms. During this
  experience, teacher-candidates/organisms are discussing with each
  other, trying to make sense of what they are experiencing. As
  Smagorinsky et al. (2016) emphasize, “... thus learning to teach [is]
  an inherently social experience” (p. 1406). Thus, internalizing
  concept definitions is also best acquired through social
  interactions.</p>
      <p>Back in the classroom, after the activity, we draw out from the
  teacher-candidates through a dialectical discussion what they observed
  and then subsequently create a definition for biodiversity and other
  featured concepts for each ecological macro-model.</p>
    </sec>
    <sec id="conclusion">
      <title>CONCLUSION</title>
      <p>Ausubel’s (1968) famous maxim regarding the role of prior knowledge
  in teaching and learning states that:</p>
      <disp-quote>
        <p>“The most important single factor influencing learning is what
    the learner already knows. Ascertain this and teach [them]
    accordingly” (p. vi).</p>
      </disp-quote>
      <p>Meaning-making is the essence of communication. Until educators at
  every level of schooling ascertain what understanding students have
  for basic concepts prior to instruction, we may in fact simply be
  making false assumptions about their grasp of the robust nature of the
  meaning within the words that are used during instruction and
  discussion. Concept definitions are the building blocks of
  intellectual activity and purposeful action. They allow for
  meaning-making within the individual, of their external world and
  effective communications between others.</p>
      <sec id="recommendations">
        <title>Recommendations</title>
        <list list-type="order">
          <list-item>
            <p>It can be argued that the lack of concept development and the
        de-emphasis on knowing what words mean is systemic in education,
        at least for the teacher-candidates and graduate students in
        this study. Thus, many of the recommendations in the 2010 study
        still apply to today:</p>
            <list list-type="alpha-lower">
              <list-item>
                <p>create a distinct, connected, compulsory subject area
            K-12 for ecological literacy,</p>
              </list-item>
              <list-item>
                <p>emphasize in those courses inclusion of concept
            definitions for key concepts in a disciplined manner,</p>
              </list-item>
              <list-item>
                <p>provide instructional strategies for concept development
            including strategies for students to learn how to be
            self-directed in formulating their own concept definitions,
            and</p>
              </list-item>
              <list-item>
                <p>provide compulsory courses in ecological literacy in
            teacher training that focus on knowing how and being able to
            teach concept development.</p>
              </list-item>
            </list>
          </list-item>
          <list-item>
            <p>At all levels, create an atmosphere and understanding that
        language development, particularly in this case of ecological
        concept development, requires a disciplined approach (Abbott,
        2002) rather than a loose, careless approach that would infer to
        the learner that words, concepts and concept definitions are
        unimportant in communications. On the contrary, the meaning of
        concepts matters!</p>
          </list-item>
        </list>
        <p>
          <bold>Funding:</bold> No funding source is reported for this
    study.</p>
        <p>
          <bold>Ethical statement:</bold> The author stated that the study
    was approved by the Lakehead University Ethics Review Board on 19
    February 2025. Informed consent is obtained through voluntary
    participation and anonymous data.</p>
        <p>
          <bold>AI statement:</bold> The author stated that no Generative
    AI nor AI based tools were used at any stage in the making of this
    research article.</p>
        <p>
          <bold>Declaration of interest:</bold> No conflict of interest is
    declared by the author.</p>
        <p>
          <bold>Data sharing statement:</bold> Data supporting the findings
    and conclusions are available upon request from the author.</p>
      </sec>
    </sec>
  </body>
  <back>
    <ref-list>
      <title>References</title>
      <ref id="B-532885">
        <title>1</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Abbott, M. B. (2002). On definitions. <italic>Journal of
Hydroinformatics, 4</italic>(2), i-xxvii.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.2166/hydro.2002.0007">https://doi.org/10.2166/hydro.2002.0007</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532886">
        <title>2</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Ausubel, D. P. (1968). <italic>Educational psychology: A cognitive
view</italic>. Holt, Rinehart and Winston.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532887">
        <title>3</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Carroll, L. (1871). <italic>Through the looking-glass, and what Alice
found there</italic>. Macmillan.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532888">
        <title>4</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Cassidy, J. R. (1967). Aristotle on definitions. <italic>Southern
Journal of Philosophy, 5</italic>(2), 110-118.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2041-6962.1967.tb02000.x">https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2041-6962.1967.tb02000.x</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532889">
        <title>5</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Deslauriers, M. (2007). <italic>Aristotle on definition</italic>.
Brill.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1163/ej.9789004156692.i-230">https://doi.org/10.1163/ej.9789004156692.i-230</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532890">
        <title>6</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Donmez, I., &amp; Gulen, S. (2023). Assessment of changes in teacher
candidates’ perceptions of the concept of the environment.
<italic>Journal of Qualitative Research in Education, 36</italic>,
54-85.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.14689/enad.36.1657">https://doi.org/10.14689/enad.36.1657</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532891">
        <title>7</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Drake, S. (1957). <italic>Discoveries and opinions of
Galileo</italic>. Anchor.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532892">
        <title>8</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Glavic, P., &amp; Lukman, R. (2007). Review of sustainability terms
and their definitions. <italic>Journal of Cleaner Production,
15</italic>, 1875-18885.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2006.12.006">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jclepro.2006.12.006</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532893">
        <title>9</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Graneheim, U. H., &amp; Ludman, B. (2003). Qualitative content
analysis in nursing research: Concepts, procedures and measures to
achieve trustworthiness. <italic>Nurse Education Today, 24</italic>,
105-112.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2003.10.001">https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nedt.2003.10.001</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532894">
        <title>10</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Henson, M. G. (1983). Effect of instruction using students’ prior
knowledge and conceptual change strategies on science learning. Part 1:
Development, application and evaluation of instruction. <italic>Journal
of Research in Science Teaching, 20</italic>(8), 731-743.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.3660200804">https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.3660200804</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532895">
        <title>11</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Kamalova, A. I. (2023). Approaches to defining the term “concept.”
<italic>American Journal of Philological Sciences, 3</italic>(11),
72-76.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.37547/ajps/Volume03Issue11-13">https://doi.org/10.37547/ajps/Volume03Issue11-13</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532896">
        <title>12</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Marr, J. W., Lynch, S., &amp; Tervit, T. (2021). Defining with
purpose: Connecting lexicogrammatical features to textual purpose in
authentic undergraduate texts. <italic>TESOL Quarterly, 55</italic>(4),
1092-1101.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1002/tesq.3081">https://doi.org/10.1002/tesq.3081</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532897">
        <title>13</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Office of Sustainability. (2025). Survey to guide Lakehead
University’s sustainability priorities and plan. <italic>Lakehead
University</italic>.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://www.lakeheadu.ca/about/sustainability">https://www.lakeheadu.ca/about/sustainability</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532898">
        <title>14</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Ontario Ministry of Education. (1988). <italic>Environmental science
curriculum guidelines, intermediate and senior divisions</italic>.
Queen’s Printer.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532899">
        <title>15</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Ontario Ministry of Education. (2008). <italic>Science, the Ontario
curriculum grades 11 and 12</italic>. Queen’s Printer.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532900">
        <title>16</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Ontario Ministry of Education. (2013). <italic>Canadian and world
studies, the Ontario curriculum grades 9 and 10</italic>. Queen’s
Printer.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532901">
        <title>17</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Ontario Ministry of Education. (2017a). <italic>Environmental
education scope and sequence of expectations, grades 9-12. A resource
guide</italic>. Queen’s Printer.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532902">
        <title>18</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Ontario Ministry of Education. (2017b). <italic>Environmental
education scope and sequence of expectations, grades 1-8 and the
kindergarten program. A resource guide</italic>. Queen’s Printer.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532903">
        <title>19</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Podsakoff, P. M., MacKenzie, S. B., &amp; Podsakoff, N. P. (2016).
Recommendations for creating better concept definitions in the
organizational, behavioral and social sciences. <italic>Organizational
Research Methods, 19</italic>(2), 159-203.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428115624965">https://doi.org/10.1177/1094428115624965</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532904">
        <title>20</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T. (2021). Intree: Embodied experience in a flat screen world.
<italic>Journal of Outdoor and Environmental Education, 24</italic>(1),
55-69.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s42322-020-00073-4">https://doi.org/10.1007/s42322-020-00073-4</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532905">
        <title>21</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T. (2023). Nurturing embodied experience: Risk tolerant parental
attitudes towards nature-based children’s learning. <italic>Education
3-13, 51</italic>(2), 200-211.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1080/03004279.2021.1957973">https://doi.org/10.1080/03004279.2021.1957973</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532906">
        <title>22</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T. (2024a). <italic>Healing the ecological self: Stop peeing in
the drinking water, start embracing the photon</italic> [Unpublished
manuscript]. Lakehead University.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532907">
        <title>23</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T. (2024b). The opaque 21<sup>st</sup> century reversed polarity
default paradigm: ON. <italic>Interdisciplinary Journal of Environmental
and Science Education, 20</italic>(4), Article e2419.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.29333/ijese/15202">https://doi.org/10.29333/ijese/15202</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532908">
        <title>24</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T. (2025). Transformative and emergent learning in pre-service
education using ecological macro models: Building resilience, agency and
self-efficacy. In <italic>Proceedings of the 17<sup>th</sup> Annual
Conference on Education and New Learning Technologies</italic> (pp.
851-858). IATED.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.21125/edulearn.2025.2283">https://doi.org/10.21125/edulearn.2025.2283</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532909">
        <title>25</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T., &amp; Stibbards, A. (2010). Ecological concept development
of pre-service teacher candidates: Opaque empty shells.
<italic>International Journal of Environmental and Science Education,
5</italic>(4), 461-476.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532910">
        <title>26</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T., &amp; Stibbards, A. (2011). Growth in ecological concept
development and conceptual understanding in teacher education: The
discerning teacher. <italic>International Journal of Environmental and
Science Education, 6</italic>(3), 191-211.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532911">
        <title>27</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Puk, T., &amp; Stibbards, A. (2012). Systemic ecological illiteracy?
Shedding light on meaning as an act of thought in higher learning.
<italic>Environmental Education Research, 8</italic>(3), 353-373.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1080/13504622.2011.622840">https://doi.org/10.1080/13504622.2011.622840</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532912">
        <title>28</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Robinson, F., Ross, J., &amp; White, F. (1985). <italic>Curriculum
development for effective instruction</italic>. OISE Press.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532913">
        <title>29</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Smagorinsky, P., Cook, L. S., &amp; Johnson, T. S. (2016). The
twisting path of concept development in learning to teach.
<italic>Teachers College Record, 105</italic>(8), 1399-1436.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9620.00296">https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9620.00296</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532914">
        <title>30</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Stibbards, A., &amp; Puk, T. (2011). The efficacy of ecological macro
models in developing ecological consciousness in preservice teacher
candidates: Transforming states of mind. <italic>International Journal
of Applied Environmental Education and Communications, 10</italic>(1),
20-30.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1080/1533015X.2011.549796">https://doi.org/10.1080/1533015X.2011.549796</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532915">
        <title>31</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Stichler, N. (2018). Enduring shared understanding: Defining and
analyzing concepts. <italic>Health Environments Research &amp; Design
Journal, 11</italic>(3), 6-10.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.1177/1937586718772635">https://doi.org/10.1177/1937586718772635</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532916">
        <title>32</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Suprapto, N. (2020). Do we experience misconceptions? An ontological
review of misconceptions on science. <italic>Studies in Philosophy of
Science and Education, 1</italic>(2), 50-55.
<ext-link ext-link-type="uri" xlink:href="https://doi.org/10.46627/sipose.v1i2.24">https://doi.org/10.46627/sipose.v1i2.24</ext-link></p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532917">
        <title>33</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Vygotsky, L. S. (1987). Thinking and speech. In R. Reber, &amp; A.
Carton (Eds.), <italic>The collected works of L. S. Vygotsky (vol.
1)</italic> (pp. 39-285). Plenum.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
      <ref id="B-532918">
        <title>34</title>
        <mixed-citation>
          <p>Wandersee, J. H., Mints, J. H., &amp; Novak, J. D. (1994). Research
on alternative conceptions in science. In D. L. Gabel (Eds.),
<italic>Handbook of research on science teaching and learning</italic>
(pp. 177-210). Macmillan.</p>
</mixed-citation>
      </ref>
    </ref-list>
  </back>
</article>